Technical and forensic support for investigation.
Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation
State educational institution of higher professional education
«Tambov State Technical University»
Chernyshov V.N., Sysoev E.V., Seleznev A.V., Terekhov A.V.
Study manual for full-time and part-time students of the specialty 030501 «Jurisprudence»
Approved by the Academic Council of TSTU as a textbook
Doctor of Historical Sciences, Professor of TSTU V.V. Nikulin
Doctor of Technical Sciences, Professor of TVVAIUR D.A. Dmitriev
Tambov TSTU Publishing House 2005
UDC 343.98 BBK 67.99(2)
T38
Reviewers:
Chernyshov V.N., Sysoev E.V., Seleznev A.V., Terekhov A.V.
T38 Forensic Science Support for Investigation: Textbook. Tambov: Publishing House of Tambov State Technical University, 2005. 80 p.
The manual provides the concept and classification of technical and forensic tools, describes the latest forensic equipment entering service with law enforcement agencies. It sets out the legal and scientific foundations of technical and forensic support.
The manual is intended for students of the legal specialty when studying the course «Technical and forensic support of investigation», it can be useful for postgraduate students, teachers of higher legal educational institutions, investigators and inquiry officers of law enforcement agencies.
INTRODUCTION
Forensic tools and methods play an important role in the fight against crime.
They allow detecting and removing invisible and barely visible traces, obtaining search and evidentiary information, facilitating the search for hiding places, providing a high degree of documentary recording of the situation in which the investigative action is carried out, and contribute to increasing the productivity of the investigator.
Recently, a number of fundamentally new technical means have appeared — devices for preliminary examination of material evidence during investigative actions.
Devices have appeared for work at the scene of explosions, fires, road accidents, for differential search of non-ferrous and ferrous metals, for detection of counterfeit money and foreign currency, for detection and removal of dust particles left by shoes on carpets, for removal of odor traces.
The range of devices based on the use of invisible rays (ultraviolet, infrared, X-ray) has been almost completely updated.
Stereo installations for photographing crime scenes and automated drawing of plans have begun to be produced. A lot of other equipment is also arriving at the scene.
However, the changes that have occurred in the technical and forensic equipment of law enforcement agencies are not adequately covered in the literature.
This manual provides the concept and classification of forensic equipment, the legal and scientific basis for their use.
It also provides information on the latest technology entering service with law enforcement agencies, and demonstrates the modern capabilities of forensic units in providing forensic support for crime investigations.
1 CONCEPT AND BASICS OF FORENSIC TECHNICAL SUPPORT FOR INVESTIGATION
1.1 Concept, meaning and classification of forensic equipment
The Russian state, having assigned the task of combating crime to law enforcement agencies, also provided them with certain means for its implementation. These means are divided into three main groups: legal, operational-search, scientific-technical.
Operational-search means are of great importance in the fight against crime.
In the course of applying operational-search measures, information systems, video and audio recording, film and photography, as well as other technical and other means that do not cause harm to human life and health and do not harm the environment are used.
It is difficult to overestimate the importance of technical and forensic means in the fight against crime. They are widely used during inspection of the scene of the incident, search, investigative experiment, other investigative actions, as well as during operational-search measures.
Their use significantly increases their effectiveness and therefore the task of law enforcement agencies is to ensure that all these means are used in a comprehensive manner. Only if this condition is met can serious success be achieved in solving crimes and exposing criminals.
This manual is devoted to only one group of the named means — technical and forensic. This choice is due to their ever-increasing importance in the fight against crime, the constant expansion of the arsenal, and the presence of serious shortcomings in the organization of their implementation and use.
When speaking about the importance of technical and forensic tools, it is necessary to first of all point out their enormous role in increasing the effectiveness of many investigative actions.
Only thanks to them it is possible to detect invisible and barely visible fingerprints, micro-objects, crime tools, jewelry hidden in hiding places, and other material evidence necessary to establish all the circumstances of the event under investigation and prove the guilt of the suspect. Technical and forensic means allow to record the situation in which the investigative action is being carried out more fully than a protocol.
When drawing up a protocol of inspection of the scene of the crime, examination, investigative experiment, presentation for identification, search, etc., the investigator may not always pay attention to individual circumstances that at first seem insignificant, but later, being recorded on photographic film, film or videotape, may prove to be significant in the analysis of the crime event.
The models of vehicles, humans and corpses available to investigators allow them to better understand the details of the event under investigation and obtain a more complete picture of the nature and method of committing the crime when investigating road accidents and interrogating victims, eyewitnesses, suspects and defendants.
The use of many technical and forensic tools has a very positive effect on the productivity of investigators.
The use of photography, sound and video recording, filming speeds up the recording of the situation in which the investigative action is being carried out, search equipment reduces the time it takes to find material evidence, special rulers facilitate the drawing up of plans and diagrams of the scene of the crime.
The importance of technical and forensic tools for obtaining search information is great. Using them directly at the scene of the incident, a preliminary examination of fingerprints, footwear, burglary tools, vehicles is carried out, and the data obtained in certain regions of the country allows for the detention of up to 70 — 80% of persons committing thefts, robberies, and armed robberies during a hot search.
It is impossible to overestimate the importance of technical and forensic tools used in laboratory research. Thanks to them, forensic experts resolve numerous issues that are sometimes of decisive importance for the event under investigation.
Technical and forensic tools are widely used in crime prevention. They help identify conditions that facilitate the commission of crimes and develop specific proposals to eliminate them.
Technical and forensic tools are also widely used in the implementation of operational and investigative activities. Forensic records, devices for compiling composite portraits of wanted persons, and other forensic equipment facilitate and speed up the detection of crimes and stolen goods.
Of course, the above only gives some idea of the significance of technical and forensic tools. It is not possible to cover this issue in more detail in this paper, since it would be necessary to touch upon the entire diversity of these tools.
Now let us dwell on the concept and classification of technical and forensic tools. Many authors approach this problem differently [1 — 7]. Let us consider the concept and classification of technical and forensic tools proposed by Professor P.T. Skorchenko [8]. In his work, P.T. Skorchenko combined the opinions of many authors.
Currently, there is a constant expansion of the classification groups of technical and forensic tools. This is partly dictated by the creation of new such tools, but most often — by the unjustified classification of other types of equipment at the disposal of law enforcement agencies as forensic tools.
Therefore, before talking about the classification of technical and forensic tools, we should distinguish them from other types of equipment.
This can be done based on the following criteria:
- the intended purpose of the technical means;
- the subject of use, i.e. what category of persons this means is intended for use by.
The intended purpose of technical and forensic means is to ensure maximum efficiency of investigative actions provided for by criminal procedural legislation, forensic examinations of material evidence, identification of conditions that facilitate the commission of crimes and development of recommendations for their elimination.
It is achieved through the use of various devices, equipment, tools, materials, special reference books and technical methods (methods, methods, techniques) for the detection, recording, removal of traces and other material evidence that are important for the case.
The subjects of application of technical and forensic means are: investigator, prosecutor, court, inquiry staff, forensic experts.
The investigator, prosecutor, court, inquiry staff may apply the specified equipment either independently or with the help of a forensic expert involved in the investigative action.
Taking into account these features, technical and forensic means can be divided into three groups by origin:
- tools borrowed from general technology and used in forensic science without any changes. These are many measuring devices (rulers, tape measures, calipers, micrometers, magnifying glasses, electric flashlights, cameras, sound recording, filming, video recording equipment, etc.);
- tools borrowed from other areas of science and technology and adapted for forensic purposes (a profilometer redesigned for the study of traces, magnifying glasses with special grids applied to them for the study of papillary patterns, etc.);
- means specially developed for forensic purposes. There are many of them, for example, mobile forensic laboratories, special comparative forensic microscopes (MSK-1) and many others.
Such classification of technical and forensic means has mainly organizational significance. It only gives an idea of the sources of replenishment of forensic equipment, the directions in which work is carried out to expand its range.
As for the classification of forensic equipment by purpose, it has not only theoretical but also great practical significance, since it allows the investigator, inquiry officer, or any other law enforcement officer to obtain a fairly clear idea of the forensic equipment available and its capabilities.
Without this, it is impossible to have any serious discussion about their widespread use in investigations.
So, according to their intended purpose, forensic equipment can be classified as follows:
- Recording equipment.These are photographic equipment, filming equipment, film projectors, tape recorders, video equipment used to record the situation at the scene of an investigative action (scene of a crime, search, investigative experiment, examination, verification and clarification of testimony on the spot, etc.), as well as various traces and objects that are important for the case.
- Means for detecting invisible and barely visible traces and other objects.These include magnifying glasses, including special forensic ones with illumination, various powders, both conventional (aluminum, graphite, soot, zinc oxide, etc.) and magnetic (iron reduced by hydrogen, ruby, sapphire, agate), sets of tools for detecting fingerprints with iodine vapor, ninhydrin and silver nitrate reagents. This group also includes devices and instruments for detecting and removing micro-objects (microvacuum cleaners, microtweezers, sticky films, etc.). We would also include here the means for the extraction of odor traces (odorological suitcases).
- Search means for the detection of various objects that may be of value as material evidence (mine detectors such as IMP and UMIF, «Gamma», «Iris», magnetic lift, trawls, probes, ultraviolet illuminators, electron-optical converters, etc.).
- Means of fixing (copying) and extraction of traces (hands, feet, teeth, burglary tools, vehicles).The most common of these means are: plaster (for making casts of shoe prints, car treads and other large objects), silicone pastes for fixing small traces (burglary tools, small sections of shoe prints), plasticine (for making casts of burglary marks), aerosol varnishes for fixing traces on loose surfaces, such as sand.
- Means for obtaining fingerprints from living persons and corpses: printing ink, fingerprint pad, board, rubber rollers and special plates for rolling out the ink, fingerprint films, fingerprint cards.
- Means for making composite portraits.This is the IKR-2 device and the computer system for making composite portraits «Frame», which is now being widely introduced into practice.
- Marker means.These means in practice, and in literature, are often called chemical traps, since they leave traces of their impact on the criminal that are difficult to remove and clearly visible. Forensic markers include various dyes, mechanical and pyrotechnic devices for spraying them, as well as ointments installed on objects with material assets that are subject to the most frequent criminal attacks. They are installed in advance, as they say: «Just in case.»
- Universal means:unified suitcases and mobile forensic laboratories intended for use in examining the scene of a crime and in carrying out other investigative actions.
- Means for systematizing and issuing forensic information.These are various card files and collections (fingerprints, footwear, vehicles, burglaries, counterfeit money and documents, and a number of others), as well as electronic computers used to maintain them, if their use is justified.
- Means for laboratory examination of material evidence.They are very diverse. These include, for example, comparative forensic microscopes, macro-reproduction units (MRK), universal laboratory reproduction units (ULARUS), the «Speed» unit for shooting firearms, «Trasograph» devices — for obtaining experimental traces of burglary tools, «PON» optical superposition devices — for examining banknotes, seal and stamp impressions, «Regula» devices — for examining money and documents.
The above are just a few of the technical and forensic tools. Law enforcement agencies have many more of them at their disposal, and they will be discussed in the following sections.
From the above, it is clear that our law enforcement agencies have a fairly large arsenal of technical and forensic tools.
If we also take into account the size of our country, the number of investigative bodies, operational units and forensic departments, it is not difficult to imagine that the state spends many millions of rubles on their technical equipment. Of course, these costs must justify themselves. Forensic technology must effectively influence the state of the fight against crime.
At the same time, as practice shows, in matters of providing law enforcement agencies with technical and forensic tools, their implementation in practical activities, and analysis of their use, they lag significantly behind the requirements. Therefore, work on technical and forensic support for crime investigations should be significantly improved. This manual is dedicated to these goals.
Technical and forensic support for investigations is understood as a system of legal, scientific, organizational measures for the development, implementation, and practical use of technical and forensic tools and scientific methods for the purpose of successful detection, investigation, and prevention of crimes [8].
Thus, technical and forensic support combines:
- legal support;
- scientific support;
- organizational support.
Within the framework of this manual, we will consider only legal and scientific support. The organizational foundations of technical and forensic support of the investigation, in comparison with the first two elements, are not so important for lawyers.
1.2 Legal foundations of technical and forensic support of the investigation
Legal support as an element of technical and forensic support for an investigation should be understood as the legal regulation of the most important issues of using forensic technology in investigative activities.
Here, four groups of questions can be distinguished:
1) on the subjects of using technical and forensic means;
2) the admissibility of using certain types of technology in criminal proceedings;
3) the procedure for using technical and forensic means;
4) procedural registration of the fact of using the equipment.
Without legal regulation of these issues, no other work on technical and forensic support of the investigation is conceivable. Therefore, legal support occupies a leading position in relation to other elements of technical and forensic support of the investigation.
Let's consider these issues.
1) Issues about the subjects of application of technical and forensic meansis not resolved by the legislator in a sufficiently comprehensive manner, since to resolve this issue it is necessary to refer not to one source, but to various regulatory legal acts due to the fact that there is no specific article regulating this provision.
Article 84 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the RSFSR of 1960 stated that “material evidence must be described in detail in the inspection report, photographed if possible, and attached to the case by a special resolution of the person conducting the inquiry, the investigator, the prosecutor, or a court ruling.”
The current Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation of 2001 contains articles that would provide an exhaustive list of subjects of application of technical and forensic means. Thus, analyzing the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation and the Law of the Russian Federation «On Operational-Investigative Activity» of July 5, 1995 with amendments of 2003, we can conclude that the subjects of application of technical and forensic means are:
a) Bodies implementing operational-investigative activity.
On the territory of the Russian Federation, the right to carry out operational investigative activities is granted to operational units:
1) internal affairs agencies of the Russian Federation;
2) agencies of the federal security service;
3) federal state security agencies;
4) customs agencies of the Russian Federation;
5) the foreign intelligence service of the Russian Federation;
6) the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation;
7) agencies for control over the circulation of narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances.Operational units of the foreign intelligence agencies of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation conduct operational-search activities only for the purpose of ensuring the security of the said foreign intelligence agency and in the event that the conduct of these activities does not affect the powers of the agencies specified in paragraphs 1, 2, 4, 6 — 9 of Part One of Article 13 of the Law of the Russian Federation «On Operational-search Activities».
The list of bodies carrying out operational-search activities may be changed or supplemented only by federal law. The heads of the said bodies shall determine the list of operational units authorized to carry out operational-search activities, their powers, structure and organization of work.
b) Investigator of the prosecutor's office, internal affairs bodies.
c) Prosecutor.
d) Court.
d) Expert.
1 Expert — a person with special knowledge and appointed in the manner established by the Code of Criminal Procedure (Article 57) to conduct a forensic examination and provide an opinion.
2 The summoning of an expert, the appointment and conduct of a forensic examination are carried out in the manner established by Articles 195 — 207, 269, 282 and 283 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation.Thus, the investigator resorts to the services of an expert in cases where it is necessary to establish:
- the causes of death;
- the nature and extent of harm caused to health;
- the mental or physical state of the suspect, accused, when doubts arise about his sanity or ability to independently defend his rights and legitimate interests in criminal proceedings;
- the mental or physical state of the victim, when doubts arise about his ability to correctly perceive the circumstances that are significant for the criminal case and to give testimony;
- the age of the suspect, accused, victim, when this is significant for the criminal case, and documents confirming his age are missing or raise doubts.
e) Specialist — a person with special knowledge, involved in procedural actions in the manner established by the Code of Criminal Procedure (Article 58), to assist in the discovery, securing and seizure of objects and documents, the use of technical means in the examination of criminal case materials, to ask questions to the expert, and also to explain to the parties and the court issues within his professional competence.
The call of a specialist and the procedure for his participation in criminal proceedings are determined by Articles 168 and 270 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. In accordance with Article 184, a specialist is called in the event of a personal search, examination of a corpse (Article 178), examination (Article 179) and in other cases.
It is true that the said articles refer to specialists in general, but as practice shows, in the overwhelming majority of cases the investigator seeks help from forensic specialists, who have at their disposal more complex forensic equipment than the investigator and experience working with it.
Therefore, a forensic specialist and an expert are among the subjects of application of technical and forensic means.
2) The Criminal Procedure Law also resolves the issue of admissibility of using certain types of equipment in investigations.
Considering this issue, first of all, we are faced with the fact that this issue is regulated by various regulatory legal acts and the absence of an exhaustive list of types of equipment.
Despite this, for example, the criminal procedure legislation contains a number of rules defining the general grounds for the use of technical means for the purpose of solving and investigating crimes.
Thus, a number of articles of the Criminal Procedure Code contain a direct indication of what equipment can be used in the conduct of an investigative action:
a) photographic equipment — Art. 82 (Storage of material evidence), Art. 166 (Protocol of investigative action), Art. 178 (Examination of corpse. Exhumation), Art. 179 (Examination), Art. 183 (Grounds and procedure for conducting a seizure), Art. 189 (General rules for conducting interrogation), Art. 190 (Protocol of interrogation) of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation;
b) filming and video recording — Art. 82 (Storage of material evidence), 166 (Protocol of investigative action), Art. 179 (Examination), Art. 183 (Grounds and procedure for conducting a seizure), Art. 189 (General rules for conducting interrogation), Art. 190 (Protocol of interrogation), Art. 192 (confrontation) of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation;
c) sound recording — Art. 166 (Protocol of the investigative action), Art. 186 (Monitoring and recording of conversations), Art. 189 (General rules for conducting interrogation), Art. 190 (Protocol of interrogation), Art. 192 (Confrontation) of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation;
d) impression materials and other materials for obtaining impressions and casts of traces — Art. 166 (Protocol of the investigative action) of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation;
d) measuring equipment — Art. 182 (Grounds and procedure for conducting a search) of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation, etc.
The use of one or another type of forensic equipment is enshrined not only in the Criminal Procedure Code, but also in other regulatory acts. Thus, the law «On the Police» in Article 11 allows registration, photographing, filming and video shooting, fingerprinting and other actions in relation to persons taken into custody, detained, accused of committing a crime, subjected to administrative arrest, etc. Article 14 of the Law of the Russian Federation «On the Police» speaks about the possibility of using «special coloring agents» (markers).
The use of forensic technology is also regulated by some by-laws. Thus, the maintenance of forensic records, the use of various methods, and devices for examining material evidence are determined by departmental instructions of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Prosecutor's Office.
However, a number of technical and forensic tools widely used in investigations are not mentioned in the law. These are search devices, video recorders, sources of ultraviolet and infrared radiation, and many others. This has been pointed out by many authors who rightly believe that there is no need to specify the entire list of technical and forensic tools in the law [2, 10, 11].
3) The Criminal Procedure Law defines the principles of using technical and forensic tools.
An analysis of the legal norms determining the use of certain forensic tools in the investigation process allows us to draw the following conclusions:
a) The investigator is independent in making decisions on the use of this or that technical and forensic means. This is indicated in particular by Article 164 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation — during investigative actions, technical means and methods of detecting, recording and seizing traces of a crime and material evidence may be used, i.e. the final decision on the use of these or that technical and forensic means remains with the investigator.
Article 166 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation, which regulates the procedure for drawing up a protocol of an investigative action, states that stenography, photography, filming, audio and video recording may be used during an investigative action. A similar provision is contained in Article 189 of the Criminal Procedure Code, which sets out the general rules for conducting an interrogation. In particular, it states that, at the initiative of the investigator, photography, audio and (or) video recording or filming may be carried out during an interrogation.
There are several exceptions to the general rules, for example: Article 82 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation states that if objects cannot be stored during a criminal case due to their bulkiness or other reasons (for example, objects subject to natural changes; objects removed from the scene of an incident due to special circumstances (removal of cars from the roadway during an accident, removal of explosive objects, etc.); perishable items and essential items), they must be photographed or filmed on video or film; Article 178 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation — unidentified corpses are subject to mandatory fingerprinting, etc.
Failure to comply with these rules shall be considered a violation of the law.
b) The use of technical and forensic means is permitted both by the investigator himself and by a specialist on his instructions.
The investigator's right to independently use technical means is enshrined in Art. 164 (General Rules for Conducting Investigative Actions), Art. 178 (Examination of a Corpse. Exhumation), Art. 179 (Examination), Art. 182 (Grounds and Procedure for Conducting a Search), Art. 189 (General Rules for Conducting Interrogation), Art. 192 (Confrontation) of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation.
The participation of a specialist is provided for in Art. 168 of the Criminal Procedure Code, which states that the investigator has the right to involve a specialist in the investigative action in accordance with the requirements of Part Five of Art. 164 of the Criminal Procedure Code, i.e. the investigator, involving participants in criminal proceedings specified in Chapters 6 — 8 of the Criminal Procedure Code in investigative actions, verifies their identity, explains to them their rights, responsibilities, and the procedure for conducting the relevant investigative action.
If a victim, witness, specialist, expert or translator participates in the investigative action, he/she is also warned of the liability provided for in Articles 307 and 308 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.
Before the start of an investigative action in which a specialist participates, the investigator verifies his/her competence, clarifies his/her attitude towards the suspect, accused and victim, explains to the specialist his/her rights and liability provided for in Article 58 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation.
c) Preliminary notification by the investigator to all participants in the investigative action about the use of technical and forensic means.
Clause 5 of Article 166 (Protocol of the investigative action) states: “The protocol must also indicate the technical means used in the conduct of the investigative action, the conditions and procedure for their use, the objects to which these means were used, and the results obtained.
The protocol must indicate that the persons participating in the investigative action were warned in advance about the use of technical means during the investigative action»; Art. 190 (Interrogation protocol); Art. 192 (Confrontation) of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation.
The legislator's emphasis on the need for advance notification of the participants in the investigative action about the upcoming use of forensic technology during its conduct is aimed at ensuring procedural guarantees for the victim, witness, suspect and accused, since they can make various requests in connection with the use of certain technical means.
For example, the victim may ask to photograph some traces of the crime (furniture broken by the criminal, a broken wall, the remains of burnt things), or to use search equipment to detect items hidden or thrown away by the criminal (a magnetic lift to extract metal objects from a well).
A suspect or accused may request that the situation in their home be photographed after a search has been conducted, during which some destruction of walls, floors, or storage facilities was carried out.
They may also ask the investigator to photograph any bodily injuries they may have suffered during a mutual fight with the victim or during detention.
Other participants in the investigative action may also express various requests and wishes in connection with the use of technology: witnesses, legal representatives, employees of the internal affairs agencies, etc.
In general, this principle is aimed at more effective use of technical and forensic tools, completeness and comprehensiveness of the investigation.
4) Mandatory procedural confirmation of the fact of use of technical and forensic tools and the results obtained from their use.
This principle is enshrined in Article 166 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation. It states that:
a) each fact of the use of technical and forensic means in the conduct of an investigative action must be reflected in the protocol (clause 5 of Article 166: the protocol must also indicate the technical means used in the conduct of the investigative action, the conditions and procedure for their use, the objects to which these means were used, and the results obtained);
b) it must contain an indication that all participants in the investigative action were notified of this on the eve of the use of technical and forensic means (clause 5, Article 166 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation: The protocol must indicate that the persons participating in the investigative action were notified in advance of the use of technical means during the investigative action);
c) the protocol must indicate which technical means were used, the procedure and conditions for their use;
d) it must record the results obtained from the use of technical and forensic means;
d) the results of the use of technical and forensic means: negatives and photographs, films, slides, interrogation sound recordings, plans, diagrams, casts and impressions of traces are subject to attachment to the protocol (clause 8, Article 166 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation: Photographic negatives and photographs, films, slides, interrogation sound recordings, video cassettes, computer information carriers, drawings, plans, diagrams, casts and impressions of traces made during the investigative action are attached to the protocol).
In addition, Article 190 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation sets forth additional requirements for the interrogation protocol: «If photography, audio and (or) video recording, or filming were carried out during the interrogation, the protocol must also contain:
1) a record of the photography, audio and (or) video recording, or filming;
2) information about the technical means, the conditions for photography, audio and (or) video recording, or filming, and the fact of the suspension of audio and (or) video recording, or filming, the reason for and duration of the suspension of their recording;
3) statements by the person being interrogated regarding the photography, audio and (or) video recording, or filming;
4) signatures of the person being interrogated and the investigator, certifying the correctness of the protocol. During the interrogation, the person being interrogated may make diagrams, drawings, sketches, charts, which are attached to the protocol, about which a corresponding entry is made in it).
All these requirements are aimed at observing the law in the use of forensic technology, guaranteeing the rights and legitimate interests of persons participating in the investigative action. If at least one of these requirements is not met, the results obtained with the use of these means in the case may lose their procedural significance.
Speaking about the requirement of the law regarding the inclusion in the protocol of the investigative action of photographic negatives, slides, films obtained as a result of the use of forensic technology, it should be noted that for technical reasons it is difficult to implement.
The fact is that at present investigators and forensic experts do not have the technical capabilities to make photographs, slides, and films directly at the scene of the investigative action.
They are made in laboratory conditions and are ready only a few days after the investigative action, while films are ready in much longer periods. Therefore, at present practice has gone in this matter along the following path.
In the protocol of the investigative action, as required by law, a list of objects photographed or filmed, shooting conditions, the number of exposed frames or films (or their footage) are indicated. In the future, when making photo tables on the title page (or in the credits of the film), as an appendix to the protocol, it is indicated what investigative action it is.
The photo table is signed by the forensic specialist who participated in the investigative action and made the photo table, or by the investigator if it was made by him personally. Negatives are attached to the photo table.
There have been no misunderstandings in connection with this procedure for attaching photographs, negatives and films to the protocols when considering criminal cases in court.
1.3 Scientific foundations of technical and forensic support of the investigation
Scientific support of the investigation by technical and forensic means is closely connected with legal support.
Professor R.S. Belkin emphasizes in this regard: “It is well known that recommendations developed by forensic science for the practice of combating crime must, first of all, comply with the requirements of legality and the principles of legal proceedings.
Legality and admissibility of application are the main criteria from which any new technical and forensic means, tactical techniques, and methodological recommendations developed by forensic science are assessed” [2].
The science of forensic science solves a large complex of issues related to technical and forensic support for investigations.
Let us dwell briefly on these issues.
1) Scientific interpretation of legislation and by-laws on technical and forensic support for investigation and development of proposals for its improvement.
As noted above, the criminal procedure legislation contains a number of articles on the use of technical and forensic means in investigation.
Often they only briefly mention certain technical means that can be used in an investigation, or indicate the procedure for procedural registration of the results obtained using them.
For practitioners, this is not enough and they have many questions about the use of technology that are not reflected in the law. All this necessitates a scientific interpretation of the law.
Taking into account the interests of practice, at present, scientific interpretation of legislation on the problem under consideration is carried out in the following areas:
— on the admissibility of using certain new technical means in investigations (video recorders, computers, etc.);
— on the subjects of using the technology, in particular, the possibility of involving specialists in the use of technical and forensic means;
— on the procedure for using technical and forensic means in the conduct of investigative actions;
— on the procedural registration of the use of forensic equipment (photography, video recording equipment, sound recording, etc.).
2) Scientific development of draft by-laws regulating forensic support for investigation.
Many issues of forensic support for investigation, as noted above, are regulated by departmental acts. The heads of departments often entrust the preparation of drafts of such documents to research institutions of the given department.
The participation of scientists in this work ensures the high quality of by-laws, their strict compliance with current legislation, which ultimately has a positive effect on the level of technical equipment of investigative bodies, inquiry agencies, expert institutions, and the level of use of the equipment at their disposal.
3) Scientific generalization of the practice of using technical and forensic tools and development of proposals for its improvement.
Law enforcement agencies have a large number of various forensic equipment at their disposal. Knowledge of the effectiveness of its use has important theoretical and practical significance.
Therefore, many forensic scientists, when working on dissertations, textbooks, and scientific articles, carefully study the practice of using technical and forensic tools, identify its positive and negative aspects, and develop proposals for its improvement.
Based on the results of studying the practice, scientists make various proposals to eliminate various shortcomings in the use of technical and forensic tools, to develop and adopt new devices, scientific methods and techniques, and others.
4) Development of new technical and forensic tools.
The most serious work on the development of technical and forensic tools is carried out by the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, which includes the Scientific Research Institute of Special Equipment, which is engaged in the development of the said tools.
This institute has developed many technical and forensic tools that are currently in service with law enforcement agencies: mobile forensic laboratories, standardized suitcases for examining crime scenes, various powders for detecting invisible fingerprints, search devices, numerous specialized devices for laboratory testing of material evidence, and a number of others.
Individual devices are being developed in forensic institutions of the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation and forensic departments of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Department of Internal Affairs. Forensic science departments of higher education institutions are also developing technical and forensic tools.
5) Scientific testing of devices and materials produced by industrial enterprises of various departments and cooperatives in order to determine the possibility of using them for forensic purposes.
In the investigation of crimes, technical means are widely used, both those specially developed for use in investigative actions and examinations, and other means produced for use in industry, scientific research, and everyday life. These are cameras, photographic materials, movie cameras, tape recorders, microscopes and other research devices, impression materials, lighting equipment, and much more.
The devices and materials of interest are carefully studied, if necessary, their samples are purchased and tested in forensic laboratories. If the results are positive, scientists make proposals to provide such devices or materials to investigative bodies, inquiry agencies and forensic departments.
Experienced forensic experts are involved in testing new technical means produced by industry for research and other purposes, along with scientists.
6) Scientific development of techniques, methods and techniques for detection, recording, seizure and examination of material evidence.
Scientific techniques, methods and methods play the same important role in investigative actions and expert examinations as technical means. Without them, technology cannot be used effectively. Therefore, in the system of technical and forensic support for investigation, serious attention is paid to the development and implementation of scientific methods and methods. Their development is essentially carried out by all research institutions of law enforcement agencies, forensic departments of law schools, and forensic specialists of practical units.
All forensic methods and techniques can be divided into two classes (groups). One of them should include methods and techniques that do not require special approval by the competent authority. These are mainly methods and techniques related to the use of technical and forensic tools in the conduct of investigative actions. The second class should consist of methods and techniques that must undergo thorough testing by specialists and be approved by the authorized body before being adopted. In essence, we are talking about expert methods here.
7) Participation of scientists in technical and forensic training of personnel.
One of the tasks of technical and forensic support of investigation is the proper technical training of law enforcement officers: investigators, inquiry officers, specialists of forensic units. An important role in solving this problem is given to the faculty of forensic science departments of law schools, scientists of research institutions of law enforcement agencies. They solve many important issues of technical training.
8) Study and dissemination of foreign experience in the use of technical and forensic tools in investigation.
In foreign countries, many forensic methods and technical means have been developed based on modern achievements of natural and technical sciences, which are successfully used in the fight against crime. Many of them are of interest to our practice.
Therefore, scientists closely monitor forensic innovations appearing abroad, publish them and publish information about them for familiarization of practitioners, and also use them in their scientific research.
2 TECHNICAL AND FORENSIC MEANS FOR INVESTIGATIVE ACTIONS
The effectiveness of investigative actions depends on many factors: the professional abilities of the investigator, weather conditions, etc.
The effectiveness of investigative actions is significantly affected by the use of technical and forensic tools during their implementation.
Currently, many different tools have been developed for use in investigative actions. Let's consider these tools.
2.1 Search tools
Material objects — carriers of evidentiary information — are very diverse and their search is often associated with significant difficulties.
This is due to the fact that some of these objects are such in size and properties that it is simply impossible to detect them with the naked eye.
For example, invisible and barely visible fingerprints, individual fibers of clothing, plant pollen, tiny particles of peeling paint, blood splashes and many other micro-objects.
Often, criminals take special measures to conceal objects that contain forensic information: they bury them in the ground, throw them into thick grass, bushes or a body of water, or hide them in specially equipped hiding places.
Various technical means have been developed and used to search for such objects.
Means of searching for invisible, barely visible and microscopic objects.
Here we are talking, first of all, about fingerprints, clothing fibers, dust, hair and other microparticles. Thus, fingerprints left on paper, glass, metal, wood, plastic products can be barely noticeable or completely invisible.
A number of technical methods and means have been developed to detect them. For example, good results are obtained by examining objects with such traces in oblique rays (the object is examined using a pocket flashlight or turned to the light source at different angles).
To search for sweat and grease traces, a special forensic magnifying glass with illumination and various powders developed for these purposes are widely used: aluminum, graphite, soot, zinc oxide, etc. (designed for dusting with a sable brush), «Sapphire», «Rubin», «Agat», hydrogen-reduced iron and new powders PMD-Ch, PMD-B (dusting is performed with a magnetic brush).
Recently, luminescent powder PMDL-S (Fig. 1) has begun to be used to detect sweat and grease traces on colored materials (paper money, bonds and other securities).
When using it, a kolinsky brush and an ultraviolet illuminator are used.
A portable fingerprint tablet called «Krug» is produced to detect fingerprints.
It is provided to both operatives and investigators.
The product includes six jars for fingerprint powders, a wide-grip magnetic brush, a squirrel hair brush, a folding magnifying glass, a fingerprint roller, a glass plate for rolling out printing ink, scissors, tweezers, a scalpel, light and dark fingerprint films, and a glass-graph pencil (Fig. 2).
Iodine vapors are a good means of detecting fingerprints. Law enforcement agencies are provided with a special set of devices called «Kit» for their use, and starch paper has been developed to fix the traces detected with iodine vapors (they quickly discolor).
Fig. 1 Magnetic fingerprint powders
PMD-Ch, PMD-B, PMDL-S
Fig. 2 Portable fingerprint tablet «Krug»
To search for micro-objects, a magnifying glass with high magnification of the «Regula» type (Fig. 3), an ultraviolet illuminator of the «Tair-1» type with autonomous power supply, an ultraviolet illuminator «Kvadrat» operating both from the mains and from the battery are used.
Ultraviolet search devices can detect blood spatter, sperm stains, fibers, and organic substances.
Search for traces of a gunshot (soot, unburned powder particles, metal particles), iron filings in places where a barrier was broken and on the suspect's clothing, as well as other objects that absorb infrared rays, is performed using S-70 devices and an electron-optical magnifying glass.
Means of searching for metal objects.
They are designed to detect cold and firearms, bullets, cartridges and cartridges, burglary tools, metal money, jewelry made of precious metals, and other metal objects.
The most widely used is the magnetic finder-lifter — a horseshoe-shaped magnet weighing 1.4 kg with a device for attaching a nylon cord 25 m long or a metal rod, this device allows you to find and extract from liquid, semi-liquid and bulk media (reservoirs, cesspools, snow, sand, etc.) objects made of ferrous metals weighing up to 35 kg.
To search for the specified objects hidden in the structures of buildings and structures, as well as in open areas, law enforcement agencies are provided with electronic metal detectors of the IMP and Iris types. The IMP mine detector began to enter service in the 1960s. Now it is being replaced by the Iris-E device, which is more sensitive and convenient to use. It can be used to inspect people and cargo (Fig. 4).
A variation of this device is the Iris-P device.
It is designed to detect metal objects made of magnetic and non-magnetic (non-ferrous) metals underwater in fresh and salt water at any water transparency at depths of up to 40 m, in currents and in stagnant water, as well as on land and at the air-water interface at temperatures from minus 5 °C to plus 35 °C.
The device provides the diver (operator) with optical and acoustic formalized information about its performance, the presence of a search object, and the discharge of the power source. Preparation for operation is carried out automatically after switching on the power supply. The weight of the device is 7.3 kg, the power source is an 18 V battery.
In connection with the increasing incidence of explosions, a set for detecting and removing fragments «Cross» has been developed and is being produced.
It includes: a lift for searching for fragments in wells, crevices, bodies of water up to 10 m deep, a probe for searching for fragments in a narrow labyrinth space, a rake for working in grass, puddles, mud, etc., a magnetic brush for examining soil, debris, snow, etc. (Fig. 5).
Fig. 3 Measuring magnifying glass «Regula» with tenfold magnification and backlight
Fig. 4 Metal detector «Iris-E»
Fig. 5. Kit for detection and removal of fragments «Cross»
Fig. 6. Selective metal detector «Kedr»
For separate detection of objects made of ferrous and non-ferrous metals in dielectric covering environments, the selective metal detector «Kedr» is produced (Fig. 6).
The device has modes of operation by type of metal and by known object. For detection of placer gold, mined by amalgamation, in luggage, hand luggage and postal items, the device «Kinovary» is produced, reacting to traces of mercury (Fig. 7).
Means of searching for non-metallic objects.
In practice, there are cases when it is necessary to find hidden containers: polyethylene canisters, tanks, boxes with various objects hidden in vehicles or people's premises, various hiding places, etc.
Various search tools are produced to facilitate their detection. The most commonly used are various metal probes used to examine upholstered furniture, containers with bulk, viscous substances, trawls for examining water bodies in order to search for corpses and various discarded items.
Fig. 7 «Kinovary» device
The device «Jasmine» (Fig. 8) is produced to search for hiding places (voids), arranged in soils, brick and concrete building structures both indoors and in the field. It allows you to detect not only voids where both metal and non-metal objects can be hidden, but also to determine the distance to them. The weight of the portable part of the device is no more than 8.5 kg.
Recently, a device for transferring dust particles «Cone» (Fig. 9) has begun to be produced.
It allows to detect and remove traces on carpets and other dielectric materials, formed by layering or removal of substances.
The maximum dimensions of the recorded dusty surface traces are 20 x 35 cm, the weight of the device is 3.8 kg, it is powered by an alternating current network with a voltage of 220 V or by two pieces of 373 elements.
For searching for people hiding in premises, or goods transported by vehicles, the device «Lavender» is produced (Fig. 10). To inspect a vehicle (its weight can be up to 15 tons), it must be placed in a room protected from the wind, since the device reacts to the heartbeat, then the wind can create interference.
The device weighs 2 kg, the device operates from dry elements 9 V or AC network 36 V. To detect violators digging in order to leave the protected area, the device «Chicory» is produced, which records vibrations of the soil during digging.
2.2 Fixation and seizure means
In the investigation of crimes, along with search means, means of fixation and seizure of objects-carriers of evidentiary information are also widely used.
Adhesive films.
Of the adhesive films, fingerprint films are the most widely used. They are available in two colors: transparent and dark.
Dark film is used to fix and remove sweat and grease traces revealed by light fingerprint powders (aluminum, zinc oxide, «Sapphire», etc.), light — to fix and remove traces revealed by dark powders (graphite, soot, copper oxide, etc.) fingerprint film is also used to remove clothing fibers, dust, plant pollen and other micro-objects from various objects.
It is also used to remove dust traces from shoes and vehicles found on leatherette, linoleum, plywood, boards, sheet iron, smooth asphalt.
For these purposes, fingerprint film is produced in large sizes (14 x 30 cm).
Recently, the «Adhesive Film Material» (AFM) has been produced, designed to record and remove fingerprints detected by fingerprint powders.
The material is almost transparent (Fig. 11).
Fig. 8 «Jasmine» device
Fig. 9. The «Cone» dust particle transfer device
Fig. 10. The «Lavender» device
A trace-copying composition in an aerosol package called «Copy» is also available for removing fingerprints at the crime scene.
When the polymer solution dries, it forms an easily removable trace-copying film on which fingerprints revealed by powders remain (Fig. 12).
Impression materials.
These include plaster, silicone paste «K», plasticine, as well as impression materials used in dental practice.
Plaster is used to make casts of three-dimensional footprints of shoes, vehicles, and animal hooves. Using paste «K», casts are made of traces of burglary tools. If traces of shoes or vehicles remain on loose surfaces, they are fixed with «Prelest» varnish in an aerosol can before making casts.
To replace paste «K», the «Kit for Removing Copies of Traces (KOS-1)» is now being produced. The kit includes two types of impression masses: liquid and viscous, providing copying of traces from various materials.
The kit also includes a container for dosing and mixing the compositions and a spatula. The resulting copies of the traces do not shrink, are durable, elastic, and accurately convey the external structure of the trace. The operating range is from -20 ° C to plus + 40 ° C. The weight of the kit is 2 kg.
Fig. 11 Adhesive film material (AFM)
Fig. 12 Trace-copying composition
in aerosol packaging «Copy»
Photographic, filming, video recording equipment.
Photography as a means of recording has been used in forensic science almost since its invention.
It is used for various purposes: capturing traces of a crime, material evidence seized during a search, recording the environment in which an investigative action is being carried out, for example, the environment of the crime scene, the environment of the apartment of the person being searched, and discovered hiding places. All arrested persons are subject to photography.
To carry out the necessary photographic work, investigators are provided with Zenit SLR cameras, a set of extension rings (for photographing traces and small objects), and a wide-angle lens (for photographing the environment in small spaces).
Investigative vehicles with a staff of more than three investigators are provided with reporter photo bags, equipped with a camera, extension rings, a short-focus Mir lens, a flash, a scale ruler, a set of numbers with stands for marking objects photographed at the scene of the incident.
For stereo photography at the scene of the incident, photogrammetric analysis of the image from the negatives of the stereo pair and automated construction of a diagram of the scene of the incident, the «Stereo-photogrammetric complex at the scene of the incident (FOMGG-1)» is produced.
The complex includes: a portable stereo photography unit based on two Zenit-avtomat cameras, an IMCL 100×50, A-1 measuring microscope; a stereoscope for individual viewing of a three-dimensional image of the crime scene; a personal computer; software.
This complex is designed primarily to record road accidents in large cities (Fig. 13).
For the most dangerous crimes, as well as in conditions where it is necessary to record the process of conducting an investigative action in dynamics (during an investigative experiment, checking testimony on site, etc.), movie cameras and video recorders of various brands are used.
In recent years, due to the complexity of film processing and film production, as well as the wider prevalence of video recorders, filming is used very rarely in investigative actions.
Fig. 13 Stereophotogrammetric complex
for recording the situation at the crime scene (FOMP-1)
Magnetic recording equipment.
Investigators have various models of dictaphones and tape recorders at their disposal. They are used in conversations with eyewitnesses at the scene of the incident, victims sent from the scene of the incident to the hospital, during interrogation of witnesses, victims, suspects, accused, during verification of testimony at the scene and in some other cases.
Fingerprinting equipment.
They are used for fingerprinting unidentified corpses and for obtaining fingerprint samples from victims and financially responsible persons, suspects and accused persons.
For fingerprinting, investigators are provided with the necessary dye (printing ink, fingerprint pad, fingerprint mastic), a rubber roller for rolling out the printing ink, a metal or plastic plate on which the ink is rolled out, and fingerprint card forms.
Fingerprint ink is known to be difficult to wash off hands. For this reason, colorless fingerprinting tablets are supplied to the sites (Fig. 14).
It contains a set of fingerprint cards soaked in a special solution and a ceramic pad also containing a special solution. During fingerprinting, the fingers are first rolled over the ceramic pad and then over the fingerprint card. After a few seconds, the fingerprint pattern on the fingerprint card becomes visible, while the dye on the finger remains invisible.
Colorless fingerprinting is used only to obtain fingerprints of victims, financially responsible persons and other citizens who may have left their fingerprints not in connection with the commission of a crime.
Their fingerprints are only needed to establish that the traces found belong to the criminals, and not to other persons.
For fingerprinting of detainees and arrested persons, special tables are made, equipped with means for obtaining high-quality fingerprints.
Fig. 14 Tablet for colorless fingerprinting
2.3 Means for preliminary examination of traces and other material evidence
During an investigation, the investigator often faces the need to conduct a preliminary examination. The term «preliminary examination» itself means that it is carried out before the appointment of a forensic examination.
The criminal procedure legislation does not provide for such an action and therefore it is of a purely operational nature.
Preliminary investigation is most often carried out with the aim of solving the following tasks: 1) determining the advisability of seizing discovered objects as material evidence and then sending them for examination and 2) obtaining information to search for criminals on the trail.
The objects of preliminary examination are traces of hands, feet, tools of burglary, vehicles, human excrement. They can also be items of clothing left or lost by the criminal (headdress, jacket, shoes), tools of crime, cargo removed from the vehicle (spilled grain, bales of hay), etc.
The investigator may conduct the preliminary investigation himself or assign it to a specialist (criminalist, chemist, biologist, etc.) involved in the investigative action. Unfortunately, the preliminary investigation of traces and other objects at the scene of the crime has not received proper application in investigative and operational-search work.
There are many reasons for this situation: underestimation of the importance of preliminary research for obtaining important investigative information, insufficient technical equipment of investigative and operational groups traveling to crime scenes, poor forensic training of investigators and operational workers, lack of proper theoretical development of the problems of obtaining investigative information from traces, etc.
At present, the following technical means and scientific methods are available for use in preliminary research.
Magnifying glasses.
The most widely used forensic magnifying glass with backlighting, which consists of two lenses: the main one with a magnification of 2.5 times and an additional one — 6 times.
The main lens is used for general examination of the object, and the additional one is used to examine individual details. The additional lens is located on the frame of the main one and moves in a circle around it. The handle of the magnifying glass has a backlight system consisting of a 2.5 V light bulb and two 316 elements connected in series. The lighting is turned on by turning the body of the magnifying glass to the right until it stops.
Measuring tools.
These include measuring magnifying glasses, such as «Regula», rulers, tape measures, compasses, calipers and some others.
With their help, traces of shoes, vehicles, tire tread details, sizes of fingerprints, burglary tools, etc. are measured and then, by calculation and comparison with data from forensic reference books, questions about the model of vehicles, their characteristic features, gender, height, age of criminals, crime tools, etc. are resolved.
Devices based on the use of invisible rays.
During the preliminary examination, mainly portable ultraviolet illuminators of the “Tair-1”, “Tair-Z” type (Fig. 15, 16) and electron-optical converters S-70, electron-optical binoculars (Fig. 17), which were already discussed above, are used.
By means of their application, the smallest particles of blood, human secretions, clothing fibers, soot from a shot, stains of fuels and lubricants, forgery in documents and other signs indicating the advisability of seizing the inspected objects as material evidence and then sending them for forensic examination are revealed.
Fig. 15 Portable ultraviolet illuminator «Tair-1»
Fig. 16 Portable ultraviolet illuminator «Tair-3»
Fig. 17 Electron-optical binoculars
The portable X-ray-visual inspection unit «Gortensia-T» is used for preliminary examination.
It is used to examine objects that may contain explosive devices, as well as locks, seals and some others.
The unit is designed for both indoor and outdoor use, ensuring complete biological protection of personnel from X-ray radiation.
Maximum current consumption is 100 μA, operating voltage is 45 kV, the screen working field size is 250 x 250 mm, overall dimensions are 1390 x 345 x 415 mm, weight is about 55 kg (Fig. 18).
Electronic devices.
Several electronic devices are currently being produced for preliminary examination. Among them is the «Kupura-K» banknote counterfeit detection kit.
The kit includes a magnetic sensor (MS) for reading magnetic codes and an ultraviolet illuminator for excitation and visual reading of fluorescent marks. The weight of the device is 0.6 kg, powered by a 9 V Krona battery (Fig. 19).
The Kaplya device is produced for express analysis of the content of precious metals.
It allows you to determine metals of the platinum group, evaluate gold and silver samples, and identify counterfeits made by applying micron layers of gilding.
The test is carried out within 3-5 seconds without leaving any traces on the test object. The device weighs 0.5 kg and is powered by a Krona battery (Fig. 20).
Due to the increasing number of explosions and theft of explosives, a highly sensitive portable gas analyzer of explosive vapors «Echo-M» is supplied to the sites.
It is designed for express measurement of micro quantities of explosives and is used in the search, inspection and examination of the detection zone of explosives and explosive devices, as well as express analysis of vapors after the unauthorized use of explosive devices (Fig. 21).
The device weighs 11 kg, and the sampler 1 kg. The power of the device is 40 W. The device uses argon gas.
It is known that one of the most common crimes is the theft of vehicles. In this case, criminals, as a rule, repaint the stolen vehicle and change its marching data.
The «Contrast» device is produced to detect such facts.
It allows you to detect changes in the thickness of paint coatings, soldering, stickers or welding of metal fragments with changed marking data on the body and parts of the vehicle.
The weight of the device is 1.9 kg, dimensions are 60 x 160 x 260 mm (Fig. 22).
A kit for express analysis of narcotic substances «Polytest».
The kit is used for express analysis of narcotic substances (Fig. 23) of plant origin and pharmaceutical products.
It includes 11 tests for the following types of narcotic substances: hemp, hashish, marijuana, raw opium, poppy straw, morphine, codeine, heroin, promedol, barbiturates, cocaine, ephedrine, amphetamines, lysergic acid (LSD).
If, after using the tests, a positive reaction is detected during examination of drugs similar to drugs, they are confiscated and sent for chemical examination.
Fig. 18 Portable installation
of X-ray visual radiation “Hortensia-T”
Fig. 19 Kit for detecting counterfeit
banknotes «Kupura-K»
Fig. 20 The «Kaplya» device for express analysis of precious metals
Fig. 21 The «Echo-M» gas analyzer for explosive vapors
Fig. 22 The «Contrast» device for detecting changes
in vehicle marking data
Fig. 23. Kit for express analysis
of narcotic substances «Polytest»
Fig. 24. Computer system for compiling
composite portraits «Frame»
Preparations for preliminary examination of traces of blood.
Blood is a very common material evidence.
However, over time it changes its color from dark red, brown to dark gray, and when rotting it becomes greenish. In addition, many substances are similar in appearance to blood (rust, dyes, juices, wine, ink, etc.).
Therefore, suspicious stains found during the inspection of the crime scene, examination, search are often subject to preliminary examination. The forensic kit of the prosecutor's investigator includes the following preparations for this: hydropyrite, Voskoboinikov's reagent, luminol.
Hydropyrite is intended for the examination of fresh traces of blood. Two tablets of this preparation are dissolved in 100 ml of boiled water, and a drop of the solution is applied to the object under examination. If blood is present, the drop of liquid boils strongly, which is clearly visible to the naked eye or through a magnifying glass.
Voskoboinikov's reagent consists of three components: benzidine, barium peroxide and citric acid, taken in a ratio of 1:4:10.
Upon receipt of the investigative suitcase from the warehouse, all components are mixed and stored in one bottle.
Before use, 0.1-0.2 g of the preparation is dissolved in 2-5 ml (1 teaspoon) of boiled water. The solution is transferred to the object under study (pieces of fabric, individual villi, etc.) using a piece of cotton wool wound around a match. If positive, the cotton wool turns blue.
However, the conclusion about the presence of blood can only be made tentatively, since some other substances also cause blueing.
The reaction is very sensitive and washing, boiling, ironing with a hot iron, treatment with gasoline, acetone, soda, ammonia have little effect on the effectiveness of this test.
Luminol is used to determine signs of blood in stains that are old (up to 10 years old) and have been in unfavorable conditions (sun, rain, snow). Washing, ironing with a hot iron, dry cleaning have little effect on the luminol test.
It should be taken into account, however, that a number of substances (beetroot juice, carrot juice, wine, ink, bile and some others) cause a reaction similar to blood.
Therefore, blood tests are carried out with a small portion of stains or individual fibers so that it is possible to present the biological expert with material that has not been treated with the reagent.
A number of other technical and forensic tools have been developed for preliminary examination, but they are intended primarily for use by forensic specialists.
Equipment for creating composite portraits of criminals.
When examining crime scenes, it is often possible to identify witnesses who saw the persons who committed the crime.
In these cases, measures are often taken to create their photofits for use in hot pursuit.
For these purposes, the «Identification Set of Drawings» (IDD) is used. It consists of an album with drawings of individual parts of the face and headgear, slides of these drawings, a device for examining the slides stacked on top of each other and photographing the resulting image of the wanted criminal's face.
The IDD is currently being actively replaced by the computer system for composing composite portraits, «Frame» (Fig. 24). The system includes a personal computer, a display, and a matrix printer.
The complete set also includes a laser printer and a scanner. The system contains elements of real photo images of a face in its memory. In addition to creating a composite portrait, the system allows you to maintain a photo library and search for faces in it by a given set of features. The program for this system is supplied to the field by the Expert and Forensic Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia.
2.4 Equipment for packaging material evidence
Articles 81 and 82 of the Code of Criminal Procedure require that items seized during an inspection of the crime scene and a search be packed and sealed, if necessary. The same need often arises during other investigative actions: examination, verification of testimony on the spot, etc.
The requirement to pack seized objects is dictated by the need to preserve traces on them. Unfortunately, in practice, this requirement is often not met, which leads to the loss of important material evidence and has a negative impact on solving crimes.
The forensic equipment supplied to investigative units for packing evidence is located in a crime scene inspection case and in a mobile forensic laboratory.
The crime scene inspection case contains:
Mailing envelopes and writing paper — are intended for packing notes, wads, pellets, bullets, cartridges, scraps of clothing, clumps of hair, pieces of wood formed during burglary, cigarette butts and other small objects.
Glass test tubes.
They are used for packing micro-objects: individual hairs, clothing fibers, scrapings from blood and other stains, tiny particles of peeling paint found during inspection of traces of burglary tools, vehicles, and other tiny objects.
Polyethylene bags of various sizes.
They are used to pack weapons, individual items of clothing, shoes, items with traces of a shot, and other similar objects.
A glass cutter is used to reduce the size of glass fragments with fingerprints.
Metalworking tools (hammer, saw, screwdriver, etc.) — used in the manufacture of containers for large, heavy objects with fingerprints, such as an axe, crowbar, etc.
Twine, plasticine, scissors — used when sealing confiscated items.
In addition to the listed tools, the mobile forensic laboratory has a device for wood burning, welding film used for packaging various objects.
The greatest difficulty in packing material evidence is caused by objects with fingerprints: bottles, glasses, glass jars, light bulbs, dishes, cutlery, etc.
It is no coincidence that they are delivered for examination either completely unpacked, which does not guarantee the preservation of traces, or bulky wooden boxes or cardboard boxes are made or adapted for their packing.
Naturally, in such cases a lot of time is spent on packaging, and its quality often does not meet the requirements.
In each investigative unit and inquiry agency, it is advisable to equip a work place for packing material evidence or create a special set for these purposes.
It should include: thick wrapping paper, cardboard sheets for making boxes, scissors, a scalpel, a stapler, paper clips, sticky film, plastic bags of various sizes or film, a wood burning device or a soldering iron for welding film, an awl, needles, harsh thread, twine, glue, postal envelopes, sealing wax, plasticine, a set of glass test tubes.
It is highly desirable to supplement this set with a puncher for punching holes in cardboard tape used for packing shards of window glass with fingerprints.
Using such a puncher, oblong holes are made in the middle of the cardboard tape in pre-marked places that coincide with the protruding parts of the glass shard.
The fragment is then inserted into them and the tape framed around it is fastened with a paper clip or a binder. Several fragments can be put into one box.
The tape can be 30…35 mm wide. The packaging is reliable, not bulky, and can be easily sealed. Holes in the tape can also be made with a scalpel or a safety razor blade, but this is less convenient and takes more time.
Most objects with fingerprints can be packed in cardboard boxes, which can be easily made by the investigator directly at the scene of the crime.
Several sheets of cardboard, a binder and paper clips for this should always be in the investigative suitcase and mobile forensic lab. The manufacture of boxes for individual items is clearly shown in Fig. 25 — 28.
Wooden boxes should be made for packing heavy objects with fingerprints (axes, weapons).
Fig. 25. Packing glass fragments with fingerprints
in homemade cardboard boxes
Fig. 26. Packing a pistol with fingerprints
Fig. 27 Packaging of cutlery with fingerprints
Fig. 28 Packaging of tableware with fingerprints
2.5 Complete forensic equipment
Complete technical and forensic tools are those that include tools for various purposes. They are created for use in the field, mainly during crime scene inspections, searches, and in some other cases.
Complete technical and forensic tools usually include forensic suitcases and mobile forensic laboratories.
Currently, law enforcement agencies have several types of forensic suitcases at their disposal, differing in purpose, configuration, and name.
The unified suitcase is the most widely used in the internal affairs agencies. It is called so because it is intended for use by investigators, inquiry officers, and forensic experts.
In recent years, it has been modified and supplied to agencies under the name of the unified suitcase «Kremen-M1», «Kremen-M2» (Fig. 29).
It contains:
- means for detecting, recording and removing fingerprints: PMD-Ch, PMD-B, PMDL-S powders, flute brush, magnetic brush, black and light fingerprint film;
- means for detecting and removing microparticles: forensic magnifying glass, adhesive film, tweezers, scalpel, glass test tubes;
- means for making copies of three-dimensional traces: plaster, elastic bowl for diluting plaster, spatula for mixing plaster, synthetic paste with hardener, plasticine; «Prelest» varnish;
- means for fingerprinting: printing ink, roller for rolling out paint, fingerprint cards;
- measuring instruments: 10 m tape measure, caliper, ruler;
- tools: hammer, various screwdrivers, chisel, metal and wood saw, gimlet;
- photographic equipment: Zenit camera, extension rings, film cassette, scale ruler;
- means for packing the seized objects: glass cutter, scissors, postal envelopes, polyethylene bags of various sizes, twine;
- means for crossing out plans: compass, writing paper, office paper.
The suitcase also contains a number of other technical means: an electric flashlight, rubber gloves, an electrical voltage indicator, gauze napkins, cotton wool and some others.
In rural areas, the functions of inquiry officers are often performed by district inspectors.
A forensic kit «Kofr» has been developed and produced for them (Fig. 30).
Fig. 29 Modernized unified suitcase «Kremneva-M1»
Fig. 30 Unified suitcase «Kofr-M»
The «Rope» suitcase is produced for inspection of road accident sites. It includes technical means for carrying out various measurements, detection and seizure of material evidence, photographic equipment. Such suitcases are provided to traffic police officers and investigators specializing in the investigation of road accidents.
The arsenal also includes suitcases for inspecting fire scenes, equipped to detect and remove typical traces and material evidence of a fire.
Some forensic science units have suitcases for removing traces of odor and suitcases for express analysis of food products seized during operational activities related to exposing counterfeit wine and vodka products, juices, confectionery, dairy and other products.
The investigative apparatus of the prosecutor's office has a slightly different forensic kit. It has both similarities with the unified suitcase «Case» and significant differences.
The similarity is manifested in the presence in both kits of means for detecting fingerprints, making casts from volumetric traces, various tools, means for fingerprinting packaging materials and some others.
The difference is that the forensic kit of the prosecutor's investigator includes search equipment and reagents for preliminary examination of traces. So, this kit has several probes.
One of them is a steel spoke with a diameter of 2.5 mm, a length of 350 mm with a sharpened end. It allows you to pierce the upholstery of chairs, sofas, bags of grain, flour, cereals, viscous liquids in containers during a search without causing any special damage for search purposes. Another probe is designed for dense soil.
It is assembled from two parts — a handle and a steel rod and is used for soil survey. It can also be used for searching objects in barrels with pickles, liquid and viscous media, in thatched roofs and other places.
Finally, the third probe, consisting of three parts: a handle, an extension rod and a conical tip — is designed to search for objects in loose soil (sand, peat), in snowdrifts, in piles of garbage, haystacks, straw, in shallow pits (probe length 90 cm), in ditches with opaque, liquid and viscous substances.
The forensic kit also includes a device for collecting soil samples. It is a hollow cylindrical pipe with a diameter of 20 mm and a length of — 100 mm. The lower edge of the nozzle is sharpened. With this device, you can take soil samples from a depth of 25 … 75 cm.
A soil sample is taken in cases where there are signs indicating that excavations may have been carried out in this place to hide some objects (stolen items, a corpse, etc.).
The forensic kit also includes a magnetic detector, which allows you to find objects made of ferrous metals in grass, loose sand, snow, cesspools, and reservoirs. It consists of a magnetic head with a device for attaching an aluminum rod or cord.
The lifting force of the head is 8 kg.
The developers of the forensic kit included a device for detecting fingerprints with iodine vapor. It seems that this should not have been done, since iodine vapor causes rust on all metal inserts of the forensic kit, and working with them without appropriate devices that limit their entry into the lungs is not safe for health.
As for the means for preliminary blood testing included in the forensic kit (hydropyrite, Voskoboinikov reagent, luminol), they have already been discussed above.
The most universal forensic kit is a mobile forensic laboratory. Currently, four modifications of such a laboratory are in operation — two in the internal affairs agencies and two — in the investigative departments of the prosecutor's office. They are developed on the basis of the UAZ-452 vehicle and on the basis of the RAF-2203.
Mobile forensic laboratories based on the UAZ-452 are supplied to regions with an insufficiently developed network of hard-surface roads, and those based on the RAF — to regions where such roads predominate.
The laboratory's special cabinets and drawers contain:
forensic investigator's kit, Veterok microparticle extraction device, ultraviolet illuminator, express examination kit, microscope, two lamps, tripods for them and 50 m of cable for connection to the power grid, camera with flash, photo enlarger with photo accessories, movie camera, video camera, portable tape recorder, magnetic lifter, electric megaphone (used when guarding the scene of the crime), magnetic lifter, portable typewriter, special clothing (waterproof raincoat, anti-mustard stockings — two pairs, oilcloth apron, cotton mittens, rubber dielectric gloves), entrenching tool (crowbar, bayonet and entrenching shovels, hammer, axe, hacksaws for metal and wood, metal scissors).
The car also has a tarpaulin to protect the body and traces in bad weather, three different probes and some other equipment.
The roof of the car is equipped with a luggage rack for transporting large-sized material evidence, which is also used when photographing the scene of the crime from above.
A flashing beacon and a turning headlight are installed above the driver's cabin, which are used to find the required house number in the dark.
As you can see, the mobile forensic laboratory is quite well equipped, but unfortunately, the technical and forensic tools available in it are not used effectively enough due to the poor technical training of investigators, who prefer to call in forensic experts when necessary.
2.6 Forensic trace-forming markers
Investigators do not use forensic markers themselves, but they often encounter them when investigating thefts from retail outlets, warehouses, pharmacies, utility rooms at enterprises, office desks at institutions, as well as bribery.
The use of forensic markers is provided for by the Law «On the Police» (clause 9, Article 11), where they are called «special coloring agents».
The main purpose of forensic markers is to create traces on the criminal at the moment of committing the crime that are difficult to wash off and clearly visible to others, facilitating his hot pursuit and subsequent identification.
The development and use of forensic markers turns random luck into a pattern, since forensic markers, when applied to a person's body and clothing, dye them in bright colors that are easily noticeable to citizens, which helps to detain the criminal.
The dyes used in trace-forming agents are quite persistent.
They can only be washed off using effective detergents, but even after removing the colored stains, dye particles remain for a long time under the nails, in the folds of the skin and are easily detected in ultraviolet rays, under the influence of which they luminesce.
As for clothing, the preparation that has gotten on it can only be completely removed by dry cleaning.
During the time until the criminal washes off the dye that has gotten on him, he meets with colleagues, salespeople, catering workers and other citizens who inevitably pay attention to the dyed parts of the body, clothing, which makes it much easier to establish his identity.
In regions where trace-forming agents are well established, they help solve up to 25% of various thefts. Forensic markers help not only solve, but also prevent thefts.
After all, a large number of people from among the criminal element become aware of their use.
Forensic markers are divided into two groups according to their purpose: for applying marks and for blocking objects with material values.
For marking money, securities, various items (for example, given as a bribe) the following are currently available:
— a set of reagents and devices «Rhododendron» (Fig. 31). It is designed to mark banknotes. The hidden inscription made is not detected by household illuminators and ultraviolet devices;
— a special product in an aerosol package «Firefly» (Fig. 32) is designed to apply a thin layer of a luminescent substance with increased adhesion to human skin and invisible under normal conditions to banknotes, documents and other objects. When fingers come into contact with various surfaces on which the product is located (for example, on a door handle), fingerprints remain visible under the influence of ultraviolet radiation with a wavelength of 365 nm. The surface area treated from one aerosol package is 1.5 m2;
— Marking markers «M» and «K» (Fig. 33) are designed to apply marks and inscriptions on various objects and documents for the purpose of their identification or prevention of counterfeiting. Marker-tip pens of the «M» type are used to apply marks on paper materials, and marker-tip pens of the «K» type are used to apply marks on objects made of metals, plastics, leather, fabrics, etc. In ultraviolet rays, marker-tip pens «M» give a blue glow, and marker-tip pens «K» give a green glow.
Fig. 31. Set of reagents and
devices «Rhododendron»
Forensic markers designed to block objects with material assets are divided into active and passive.
Active forensic markers are those that have a device for ejecting a dye into space and thus ensuring that it gets on the clothes and exposed parts of the body of the person who activated the device. The dye can be ejected either by mechanical devices, such as a spring, or by an explosive in special pyropatrons.
Recently, liquid markers «Kupel» (Fig. 34) have been produced. They are designed to combat theft of personal and state property. When an object is opened without authorization, the contact is closed and an instantaneous emission of sprayed dye occurs, which retains a bright red color for three days, as well as luminescence in ultraviolet rays. The range of dye emission is at least 1.5 m. The volume of dye is 1.5 ml. This marker can be used in a special device «Kern». The latter has a device for connecting two «Kupel» products to it. The triggering occurs from a signal from a magnetic sensor or by means of mechanical contact. The dispersion area is 5 m.
Recently, chemical traps «Kukla-MG», «Koshelek», «Kredit» (Fig. 35 — 37) have been produced.
The chemical trap «Kukla-MG» is made in the form of a banknote pack with a capacity of 100 sheets. When it is removed from the scene of the incident, a dye composition is ejected and tear gas is sprayed.
The «Koshelek» trap has the form of a wallet. When it is opened, a dye is sprayed and an 80 dB siren is activated, and the «Kredit» trap is made in the form of a banknote pack of ten packs.
Fig. 32 Special product “Firefly”
Fig. 34 Forensic marker “Kupel”
with an electric charge igniter
Fig. 35 Forensic marker «Kukla-MG»
During a robbery, the product is handed over to the robbers along with real money, and 5 minutes after the transfer, a tear gas composition is sprayed and an intense release of orange smoke occurs, which greatly complicates the criminals' ability to escape.
The «Kapral» device is produced for remote marking of various material objects and offenders. It includes two capsules with a coloring agent, five pyrotechnic capsules with a tear gas and an electric flashlight for illuminating documents in the dark.
Passive forensic markers do not have any triggering devices. Their design is intended for direct contact with the person committing the crime. In passive forensic markers, the coloring substance in the form of powder mixtures or ointments is applied either directly to the object that may attract the attention of the criminal, or is placed in bags, paraffin capsules or other packaging and is disguised among such objects.
Fig. 36 Forensic marker «Wallet»
Fig. 37 Forensic marker «Credit»
Passive markers are camouflaged in the packaging of wine and vodka products, firearm holsters, bank packages, ladies' and collector's bags, payphone receivers, boxes for various souvenirs and expensive candies, chocolate bar wrappers, in boxes for narcotics, etc. When such objects are opened, the dye spills out and the coloring substance gets on the body and clothes of the intruder. Often, ointments are prepared on the basis of Vaseline and coloring substances, which are used to treat specially prepared rugs. At the end of the working day, they are placed near the doors, on the windowsills, and if the criminal enters through the doors or windows, his shoes are painted in a bright color and it is possible to trace his route from the scene of the crime, and then use it as evidence in the case.
The product «Carpet» is used in a centralized manner. It consists of a fabric backing with microcapsules with the odorant substance SP-80 MS glued to it. When the capsules are exposed to a person's foot, they are destroyed, the drug gets on the sole of the shoe, which significantly increases the performance of service and search dogs.
The activation of active forensic markers is accompanied by a certain noise (a pyrotechnic cartridge shot, a spring click) and is always obvious to the criminal. When a passive marker is activated, the criminal may not know this fact and discovers it only after some time.
The same object can be blocked by both active and passive forensic markers. In this case, objects that facilitate leaving fingerprints of the criminal are often installed along with forensic markers.
The following requirements are imposed on forensic markers.
-
They must not be dangerous to human life and health.
-
The design of forensic markers must be constantly changing. When using the same forensic marker designs, criminals will quickly learn to recognize them and will not touch them when committing thefts. Using different types of markers allows you to avoid this.
-
Forensic markers must be reliable in operation, designed for long-term use in various climatic zones.
-
Forensic markers should be simple in design, designed for the use of improvised materials and unskilled labor for their manufacture (police school cadets, etc.). Only ejection devices are manufactured in factories — pyropatrons, mechanical devices, basic mixtures of dyes. They are the basis for any design developed directly on site. This ensures a huge variety of forensic markers, which does not allow criminals to recognize them when committing crimes.
-
Forensic markers must be cheap. This requirement is put forward due to the fact that a huge number of objects are blocked by these means and if they are expensive, then significant funds will be required for their manufacture.
Practice has developed the following procedure for using trace-forming agents. Criminal investigation officers determine the type of objects to be blocked by these agents and their quantity. In accordance with this, together with employees of forensic units, the design of forensic markers is developed, and their production is organized. The composition of the coloring agent is determined by a chemist based on the supplied basic mixtures applicable to a separate territorial zone. The latter is important, since when a suspect is detained, the area where the crime was committed can be determined based on the substance found on him.
The fact of installing forensic markers on an object is documented by a report of the established form, drawn up by a criminal investigation officer or a district police officer. It specifies the name of the blocked object, the position and surname of the police officer who installed the forensic marker. The surname, first name, patronymic of the financially responsible person, the appearance of the forensic marker and the «predatory substance» used in it (without its exact name). The financially responsible person is given detailed instructions on the rules for handling the forensic marker and is warned not to disclose the fact of its installation. A sealed bag with a sample of the dye is attached to the report. The list of all objects blocked by these means is kept in the duty unit of the internal affairs agency and is used to inform the investigative team leaving for the scene of the incident upon receiving a report of a theft. The fact of the forensic marker being triggered is reflected in the crime scene inspection report and urgent information is sent to the task forces via radio to search for the criminal on the spot. A sample of the dye is attached to the report if it was partially spilled as a result of the forensic marker being triggered.
There are often cases when criminals take a forensic marker (often a passive one) with them. In such cases, the investigator indicates in the inspection report that, according to the financially responsible person participating in the inspection, a forensic marker was in such and such a place the day before the theft, but was not found at the time of the inspection. More details about this are recorded in the interrogation report of this person. The act of blocking the object with a forensic marker and the sample of the dye attached to it will be requested from the police agency and attached to the criminal case.
If a suspect is identified, an immediate examination and inspection of his clothing, a personal search, a search at his place of residence and work are carried out. In all cases, an ultraviolet illuminator is used. If a substance that could have been formed by a forensic marker is found on the body, it is removed using a gauze swab, and clothing with traces of such a substance is packed and sent for physical and chemical examination.
It is advisable to entrust the examination to the forensic department of the local Ministry of Internal Affairs, Department of Internal Affairs, since the experts of this department are well aware of the methods of studying the substances used in forensic markers. Before the examination, two questions are usually asked: 1) what is the composition of the substance that caused the stain on the clothes or body of the suspect and 2) does it match the composition of the substance of the forensic marker installed on the object from which the theft was committed. For a comparative study, a sample of the substance attached to the act of blocking the object with a forensic marker is sent for examination along with the clothes (swab).
3 PROVIDING INVESTIGATION WITH FORENSIC INFORMATION
3.1 The concept of forensic information and its importance in the investigation
Forensic information is systematized data on people, corpses, methods and means of committing a crime, stolen items, traces and material evidence, as well as other objects that are important for investigating crimes. Taking into account the interests of practice, the types of records containing forensic information are constantly expanding.
Forensic records — sources of forensic information consist of the following elements: accumulation of information, its systematization, identification of registered objects and issuance of reference information.
Accumulation of information occurs due to the receipt by the divisions that carry out the registration of registration cards from investigative and operational units on the crimes under investigation and the suspects and accused involved in them, reports from judicial bodies on the results of the consideration of criminal cases, operational reports on crimes and the methods of their commission, and the signs of criminals. An important source of the information taken into account are also expert opinions on the results of the examination of material evidence. In order to quickly find the incoming information, it is systematized. For each type of registration, its own system of information arrangement has been developed.
Identification of the registered information is carried out by the employees who carry out its registration. In some cases, computers are used for these purposes.
Information is issued at the request of the investigator, inquiry officer, or court, who, if necessary, send a request of the established form to the units implementing the records. The results of the check are indicated on the reverse side of these requests, and they are returned to the initiator of the request. In emergency cases, the records are checked by telephone or telegraph.
All records are currently maintained by the internal affairs agencies, and the procedure for their creation and use is regulated by the instructions of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation. This, however, does not mean that records are used only by investigators and inquiry officers of the internal affairs agencies. They are interdepartmental in nature, and investigators from all law enforcement agencies seek their assistance when investigating crimes.
Currently, the importance of forensic records is determined by the fact that they:
-
allow you to quickly and reliably establish information important for the investigation about suspects and accused persons: whether they were previously convicted, when, for what, where they served their sentence, etc.;
-
facilitate the disclosure of non-obvious crimes. Many records, including fingerprinting, bullet and cartridge case libraries, records of lost, found, stolen and voluntarily surrendered weapons, stolen items, etc., allow us to obtain information directly indicating the possible involvement in the crime of a specific person who has been suspected;
-
facilitate the detection and seizure of objects of criminal encroachment — stolen during thefts, robberies, robberies, murders and rapes involving theft of valuables. It is for these purposes that forensic records of stolen, found and seized items, antiques and fine art have been created;
help to establish missing persons and the identity of unidentified corpses — according to the records of corpses and missing persons; -
accelerate and facilitate the verification of investigative and operational-search versions, for example, versions that provide for the possibility of committing a similar crime by those previously convicted of a similar crime, escaped from prison, etc.
Forensic records also help to solve a number of other issues that arise during the investigation of crimes and the implementation of preventive measures. The effectiveness of using forensic records depends on the knowledge of practitioners of its capabilities, as well as on their initiative and timely appeal to their assistance.
According to the volume of information included in the records, they are divided into centralized (federal) and territorial (regional). Centralized records are those that contain information on the scale of the Russian Federation (previously on the scale of the USSR), and local records are those that contain information on the scale of the republics, territories and regions that are part of the Russian Federation.
3.2 Providing the investigation with forensic and reference information on individuals and corpses
Forensic records of living persons are the most common compared to other forensic records. They include those arrested and convicted for crimes committed, unknown criminals, missing persons, suspects of forging medical prescriptions for obtaining narcotics in pharmacies, owners and drivers of vehicles, and unknown patients. Let's consider these records and the possibilities of their use in an investigation.
Surname and fingerprint records.The following are on the Federal Register (in the Main Information Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia):
a) convicted in the territory of Russia to the exceptional measure of punishment — the death penalty and imprisonment, regardless of the composition of the crime and the term of punishment;
b) convicted in a foreign state and transferred to Russia to serve a sentence or materials about whom are received in accordance with treaties on legal assistance and legal relations in criminal cases, regardless of the type of punishment;
c) convicted to restriction of freedom, in respect of whom the court has issued a determination to send to places of imprisonment;
d) persons sentenced to imprisonment with a deferred sentence, in respect of whom the court has issued a ruling on sending them to places of imprisonment to serve the sentence imposed by the sentence;
d) persons wanted by security and internal affairs agencies.
In addition to the above categories of convicted persons, the following are also registered locally (IC MVD, GUVD, UVD of the republics of territories and regions that are part of the Russian Federation):
a) all convicted, arrested and charged on the territory of the republic, territory, region, regardless of the composition of the crime, the term and type of punishment, the chosen measure of restraint;
b) convicted in other republics, territories, regions to the exceptional measure of punishment, as well as to imprisonment, who arrived to execute the sentence or serve the sentence in the given republic, territory, region;
c) persons who have committed crimes, materials on whom, without initiating a criminal case, have been sent for the application of measures of social influence;
d) persons who have committed socially dangerous acts, placed by a court decision in psychiatric hospitals for compulsory treatment, as well as transferred to the care of relatives or guardians.
To check the surname register, a request of the established form is filled out and sent to the territorial information center, and if there is reason to believe that the person being checked was held accountable in another republic (territory, region), then the request is also sent to the Main Information Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation for checking the federal register.
The results of the check are reflected on the back of the specified requirements. Here, information is provided on all convictions, changes in sentences, grounds and time of release for the last conviction, insanity of the person, place of serving the sentence with the indication of the postal address. Requests are executed within three to five days.
Closely related to the surname register is the fingerprint register. Suspects and accused persons who do not have identification documents or who are questionable are checked using fingerprint register. In these cases, fingerprint cards of those being checked are sent to information centers. Fingerprint register is also used to establish the identity of unidentified corpses. Positive results in this case can only be obtained if the deceased was previously convicted and held in custody. Fingerprint register of persons convicted of crimes is sometimes used to check fingerprints seized in unsolved crimes.
Registration of qualified and especially dangerous criminals.This category of persons is registered using the «Dossier» subsystem. In the Main Information Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, this system is linked to a centralized photo library, which stores photographs of persons registered.
Suspects, accused and convicted persons are registered. The selection of persons subject to registration is carried out by investigators of the internal affairs agencies and the prosecutor's office not on an article-by-article basis, but based on the importance of the information for the detection, investigation and prevention of crimes, as well as for the improvement of forensic tactics and methods for the detection and investigation of crimes. Only persons included in the most criminal group of offenses are subject to registration:
a) having a persistently expressed criminal orientation: bandits, rapists, currency dealers, smugglers, speculators, extortionists, drug dealers, weapons manufacturers, drug manufacturers, brothel keepers, robbers, housebreakers, counterfeiters, embezzlers, black marketeers, weapons dealers, car thieves, murderers, safecrackers, antique dealers, swindlers, bribe takers, terrorists, prostitutes, racketeers, etc.
b) committing crimes characterized by the following features: interregional focus, professionalism of execution, exceptional audacity, particular cruelty, cynicism, in relation to children, in relation to government officials and deputies, in relation to law enforcement officers, seriality.
Recording is carried out using a computer.
Recording of missing persons, unidentified corpses, unknown patients and children.The objects of this registration are citizens of the Russian Federation, as well as the CIS, foreign citizens and stateless persons who have lost contact with their relatives (or in connection with the application of representative offices located in the territory of Russia). The following are subject to registration:
-
persons who have disappeared without apparent reason, whose whereabouts and fate remain unknown;
-
minors who have left home without permission;
-
minors who have escaped from boarding schools, orphanages and other institutions where they were kept; — mentally ill persons who have left home or medical institutions;
-
persons who have left nursing homes and homes for the disabled without the knowledge of the administration;
-
unidentified corpses of citizens;
-
persons in mental hospitals and other medical facilities, homes for the disabled and elderly, orphanages and boarding schools, who, due to their state of health, cannot provide any information about themselves.
The basis for registration is a resolution on the initiation of a case to identify an unknown person.
Registration of persons declared wanted.This registration is intended to ensure federal search activities for persons hiding from authorities.
The following persons are registered:
-
who have committed illegal acts and are hiding from investigation and trial;
-
those who have escaped custody or trial;
-
those who are conditionally convicted or conditionally released;
-
those who have voluntarily left work at national economic facilities;
-
those who evade payment of monetary amounts in accordance with claims by enterprises and organizations (government debtors) or citizens (alimony defaulters);
-
those who have disappeared without apparent reason (missing persons).
In the Main Information Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, the centralized registration of wanted persons is carried out by the automated information system (AIS) «VR-Notification». Written requests for verification of these records are executed within 24 hours from the moment of receipt by the information center, and telephone requests — directly at the time of the request.
3.3 Providing the investigation with forensic information on crimes and stolen goods
During an investigation, it is very important to establish crimes committed in a similar manner. For this purpose, qualified and especially dangerous types of crimes are recorded. The following are recorded: violent crimes, qualified thefts of property, thefts from metal storage facilities, car thefts, thefts of cargo in transport, organization of criminal activity, crimes against public safety and justice, counterfeiting and forgery of documents, theft of production resources and raw materials, financial and currency fraud, drug trafficking, smuggling, corruption.
The objects of recording qualified and especially dangerous crimes are: intentional murders, sexual offenses, threats to kill, robbery, banditry, sabotage, necrophilia, serious bodily harm, torture, malicious hooliganism, extortion, hostage-taking, terrorist acts. Depending on practical needs, the list of crimes recorded may change.
In addition to the listed crimes, other crimes are also recorded that are characterized by the following features: interregional focus, professionalism of execution, exceptional audacity, particular cruelty, cynicism, committed against children, government officials and deputies, law enforcement officers.
Both unsolved and solved crimes are recorded.
The selection of crimes subject to registration is carried out by investigators of the internal affairs agencies and the prosecutor's office not on the article principle, but based on the importance of the information for the disclosure, investigation and prevention of qualified, especially dangerous, serial, interregional crimes, as well as for improving the methodology of their investigation.
This registration is carried out using a computer.
Registration of stolen, confiscated, as well as lost, found, surrendered weapons.This registration is carried out in order to assist in solving crimes committed with the use of firearms. The following are registered: combat, hunting and sporting rifled weapons, grenade launchers, flamethrowers, portable barrel and rocket artillery shells, explosive devices of remote, electromechanical and manual control.
Weapons registration in territorial information centers is carried out manually, and in the Main Information Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation — based on the use of a computer (the «Weapons» subsystem).
The check of the records can be carried out both upon written request (the check is carried out within 24 hours) and by teletype.
Record of stolen and hijacked vehicles. This record is intended for use in the implementation of operational and investigative measures to detect stolen or abandoned vehicles. It is also used when registering vehicles in the traffic police departments. The record is automated (the «Autosearch» system).
All domestic and imported passenger and freight vehicles of all known models and brands are registered.
Registration of stolen antiques and cultural valuables. This registration is organized to ensure the search for stolen antiques and cultural valuables and to assist in solving crimes related to their theft.
The following stolen and recovered items of historical, artistic or scientific value are registered:
-
archaeological finds, antiquities;
-
anthropological and ethnographic items;
-
historical relics (geodetic maps, badges of honor, medals, stamps, manuscripts, rare printed documents, rare books, religious photographs, facsimile reproductions);
-
artworks (paintings, graphics, drawings, sculptures, miniatures, icons);
-
applied art items (dishes, vases, clocks, cutlery, jewelry, items of women's and men's toilet, chests, caskets, boxes, snuffboxes, furniture, objects of religious rites, weapons, musical instruments).
The card index in the information centers of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the Main Directorate of Internal Affairs, and the Department of Internal Affairs is maintained both manually and using a computer. In the Main Information Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, the accounting is fully automated (the «Antiques» subsystem). When accessing the accounting, information is provided on the identification features of antiques on the register, the initiator of the search for these items, the place and method of theft, data on the owner, statistical information on the accounting. The check of the accounting is carried out by teletype, telephone and written requests. Written requests are processed within 24 hours.
Accounting of stolen and confiscated documents of general state circulation and numbered items.This record is kept to facilitate the search for stolen and confiscated documents, items that had individual numbers or characteristic features, as well as to assist in solving crimes related to them.
Stolen and confiscated numbered items, as well as documents and securities of national circulation registered in territorial information centers, are placed on centralized record in the Main Information Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation.
The reference to the register is made mainly to establish whether the document (thing) being checked is registered, by whom and in connection with what it was registered, who is the owner. In the event that it is established that the identified item is listed as lost, the internal affairs agency that registered it, as well as the agency that identified the item, are immediately notified.
3.4 Providing the investigation with forensic information on seized material evidence
Practice knows of numerous cases of several crimes committed by the same persons before their arrest. In order to facilitate the timely disclosure of such crimes, records of material evidence and some other objects that help to identify criminals and fully expose them are organized. Records of material evidence (or their photographs, casts) are kept in the forensic departments of the internal affairs agencies, since work with such objects requires expert training and special research equipment.
Let's consider these records.
Record keeping of fingerprints recovered from unsolved crimes (fingerprint archives).This record is used to establish the facts of fingerprints left by the same person at several crime scenes, as well as the facts of fingerprints left at crime scenes by specific suspects. Investigation files are maintained in all forensic science divisions of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the republics that are part of Russia, the Main Directorate of Internal Affairs, the Directorate of Internal Affairs, the Department of Internal Affairs for Transport, as well as in city and district police agencies that have forensic experts on staff. The card file contains photographs of fingerprints from unsolved murders, robberies, thefts, rapes, fraud, vehicle theft, and other crimes. The card file is used to check detainees registered for operational investigations, and other individuals detained and delivered to internal affairs agencies if there are grounds to suspect them of committing a crime. When checking specific individuals using fingerprint files, in addition to a written assignment, a fingerprint card of the person being checked is sent.
Several thousand different crimes are solved every year with the help of fingerprint files and auxiliary fingerprint files. At the federal level, fingerprint files and auxiliary fingerprint files are not maintained due to their low efficiency.
Collections of spent bullets and cartridge cases with traces of weapons (bullet and cartridge case files).The Bullet Gun Library operates in the Expert-Criminalistics Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia. It is intended to establish the facts of the use of the same weapon by criminals in committing several crimes in the territory of different regions, as well as the use of confiscated and voluntarily surrendered weapons in committing specific crimes.
The bullet and cartridge library functions based on the concentration of bullets, cartridge cases and cartridges with traces of firearms, as well as control bullets and cartridge cases fired from stolen or lost service weapons of the internal affairs agencies (the latter are fired upon entering service, and the bullets and cartridge cases are stored in a warehouse, from where they are removed and sent to the bullet and cartridge library in the event that the weapon is lost). Cartridges and cartridges of smoothbore weapons are not taken into account.
The bullet and cartridge case library is used to check all weapons confiscated in criminal cases, found and voluntarily surrendered, as well as, if necessary, weapons surrendered by institutions and organizations that were in their use on legal grounds.
To check the weapon against the bullet and cartridge case library, it is sent to the local forensic unit, where it is fired. Three shots are fired from each weapon into a special bullet catcher, and if there are removable magazines, three shots are fired using each magazine. The experimentally fired bullets and cartridge cases are sent to the Forensic Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation for checking against the bullet and cartridge case library. The fired weapon is stored in the forensic unit until a response is received from the Forensic Center, which, if necessary, may request the weapon for additional shooting and examination. Certificates on the results of checking bullets, cartridges, cartridges with traces of weapons, as well as the weapon itself, are attached to the criminal case.
Collections (card indexes) of counterfeit banknotes.Card indexes of counterfeit banknotes are maintained in forensic science departments that have sufficient equipment and specialists to conduct physical and chemical research. The Federal Card Index of Counterfeit Money is maintained in the Forensic Science Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia. The card index functions to establish the common origin of counterfeit coins, securities, treasury and bank notes, currencies of foreign countries by the method and technology of production, as well as to identify persons engaged in their production.
All counterfeit banknotes found are subject to verification in the federal card index. The verification is carried out within five days. In emergency cases, the verification can be carried out by telephone, teletype, or fax. In this case, the request specifies the denomination, series, number, and manufacturing technology of the banknote, and for foreign currency, the country, series and number of the ticket, series and number of the cliche, year of issue, name of the bank, and manufacturing technology are also reported. If the verification results are positive, the investigator conducting the investigation into the discovery or seizure of the counterfeit banknote is immediately notified of this.
Collection of counterfeit documents produced by printing.Collections of counterfeit documents produced by printing are maintained in forensic science departments, and the federal collection is maintained in the Forensic Science Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia. The collections function to establish the common origin of counterfeit documents, forms printed from the same typographic set, cliché, or printing form, as well as to identify the persons involved in their production. The collection includes driver's licenses, certificates, diplomas and other documents, in the production of which criminals used the printing method of producing forms.
Each document produced by a printing method that raises doubts about its authenticity is sent to the forensic science division for examination by the investigator or the person conducting the inquiry. If it is established that it is counterfeit, it is photographed one by one, the photographs are pasted onto cards indicating the time and place of the document seizure, the owner's name, the series and number of the document, the number of the criminal case, by whom and when it was initiated, the number of the expert's report, and known data about the manufacturer or distributor of counterfeit documents. Before placing the card in the collection, a check is made against its existing array in order to identify similar documents. The cards are arranged in the collection by type of document, method and technology of their production or the distributor of counterfeit documents. The second copy of the card is sent to the Forensic Science Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia for placement in the federal collection.
All questionable documents produced using printing equipment are checked against the collection.
The results of the check are documented in a certificate, which is sent by the forensic unit to the investigator or the person conducting the inquiry for inclusion in the criminal case.
Collections of traces of burglary tools, shoe soles and tire treads of vehicles.This collection is intended to establish the facts of the use of the same object in the commission of one or more crimes. They are created only in those regions where this is dictated by the operational situation.
The collection is formed by objects submitted for examination. After the examination, traces of burglary tools, footwear, and vehicle tire treads, recorded using trace-copying materials, are placed in the appropriate trace files. Photo reproductions of shoe prints and tire treads, made on a one-to-one scale, may be placed in the trace files. The investigator or the person conducting the inquiry is informed about the placement of traces in the trace file in the cover letter to the expert's report.
Before placing a trace in the collection, it is checked against existing traces. If a match is found, the investigator who ordered the examination and the head of the criminal investigation department in whose territory the crimes were committed are immediately informed.
Traces from unsolved crimes are kept in the card index for two years, after which they are returned to the investigative unit conducting the investigation.
Collections of counterfeit medical prescriptions for narcotic and potent drugs and samples of the handwriting of persons engaged in their counterfeiting.
They are intended for:
a) identifying the executors of handwritten texts of counterfeit medical prescriptions;
b) combining the handwriting of the executor of counterfeit medical prescriptions received by forensic units from internal affairs agencies;
c) analysis of methods of counterfeiting prescriptions and techniques for their use with the aim of developing proposals for the technical protection of prescription forms and preparing information messages for internal affairs agencies and medical institutions.
Collections (card indexes) of micro-objects.They are conducted by physical and chemical laboratories of forensic departments of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, Main Directorate of Internal Affairs, Directorate of Internal Affairs, Directorate of Internal Affairs of Transport and are intended to establish the fact of homogeneity of origin of micro-objects found at crime scenes and seized as samples from suspects.
The collection is formed by objects submitted for physical and chemical examination. After the examination, the data on the results of the study of micro-objects (photographs, spectrograms, graphs, information on the structure, composition and mechanism of formation, diagrams and localization on carrier objects) together with general information on the crime are placed in a card index. By agreement with the person who ordered the examination, the micro-objects themselves can be placed in the card index. If, as a result of comparing newly received objects with micro-objects already in the array, a match is established, this is immediately reported to the criminal investigation department in whose territory the crime was committed and to the investigator who ordered the examination.
After a year, the micro-objects are removed from the card index and returned to the person who ordered the examination.
Collections (card indexes) of subjective portraits.These collections are maintained in forensic science departments and are intended for use in the search for and identification of unknown criminals who have escaped and the search for persons who knew or saw the wanted criminal.
Subjective portraits are compiled by employees of the forensic science department at the initiative of criminal investigation officers who have identified the persons who saw the criminal and can name his features. The prepared subjective portraits are pasted onto cards of a uniform sample, checked against the available array and placed in a card index. If necessary, photographs of suspects can be checked against this card index.
4 CAPABILITIES OF FORENSIC SCIENCE DEPARTMENTS IN TECHNICAL AND FORENSIC SUPPORT OF THE INVESTIGATION
4.1 Forensic science departments as a subject of technical and forensic support of the investigation
Investigation of crimes is a complex process of human activity, requiring certain knowledge and skills from the investigator. The basics of such knowledge and skills are acquired in law schools during lectures, seminars and practical classes. However, they are clearly insufficient when it comes to the qualified use of technical and forensic tools for the detection, recording and seizure of material evidence, as well as the extraction of search and evidentiary information from them. Therefore, forensic units have been created to assist the investigator.
Currently, such units operate in the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the Ministry of Justice, the Ministry of Defense, the FSB, the Customs Committee, and the tax police in Russia. The forensic units of the Ministry of Internal Affairs serve the investigative apparatus and operational apparatus of the internal affairs agencies. The Ministry of Justice serves the investigative apparatus of the prosecutor's office and judicial bodies. The Ministry of Defense, where forensic units operate as part of forensic laboratories, serves the investigators of the military prosecutor's office. Of all the units that have them, the most numerous are the forensic units of the internal affairs agencies.
The Forensic Science Center is the head of the forensic science divisions of the internal affairs agencies. It develops and monitors the implementation of guidelines on the activities of the forensic service, analyzes its work, and ensures its active participation in the fight against crime.
The vast majority of employees of forensic science divisions are forensic scientists: fingerprint experts, trace experts, ballistic experts, handwriting experts, and specialists in technical examination of documents and photographs. The division also employs physicists, chemists, automotive technicians, firefighters, and other specialists.
The main tasks of forensic units of internal affairs agencies are the use of forensic tools and methods on assignments from investigative and operational units, inquiry units of internal affairs agencies for the purpose of detecting, recording, seizing and examining traces and other material evidence.
To solve these tasks, forensic units perform the following functions in terms of technical and forensic support for investigations:
a) conduct expert examinations in criminal cases, as well as research on operational materials;
b) ensure the participation of their specialists in the production of investigative actions and operational-search measures;
c) maintain expert-criminalistic card files and collections;
d) independently or jointly with investigative and operational units, analyze the practice of using forensic tools and methods in combating crime, develop and implement measures to improve the organization and enhance the quality of this work;
d) provide assistance to investigative and operational units in organizing the use of forensic tools and methods, and also provide these services with information on the capabilities of forensic units in combating crime;
e) identify, summarize, disseminate and implement best practices in organizing the use of forensic tools and methods in investigative and operational-search activities of internal affairs agencies;
g) organize and implement activities on technical operation, metrology and repair of forensic equipment available in forensic units, develop and make proposals to management on increasing the efficiency of its use, participate in the distribution and redistribution of existing and newly received forensic equipment between internal affairs agencies, develop a table of equipment allocations taking into account the actual need and the standards approved by the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia;
h) identify, on the basis of an analysis of materials from expert practice and other forms of activity, conditions conducive to the commission of crimes and develop proposals for their elimination;
i) conduct rationalization and inventive work to improve and modernize forensic equipment;
k) carry out, at the request of investigative and operational units, internships for their employees in order to impart to them practical skills in the use of the equipment available to them.
Let us briefly consider the capabilities of forensic units in conducting forensic examinations.
4.2 Capabilities of forensic units in conducting forensic examinations
Forensic examination is widely used in the investigation of crimes. It helps to resolve many important issues that affect the quality of the investigation. Thus, by conducting examinations, it is possible to successfully verify various investigative versions about the motives of the crime, the method and means of committing them, the involvement of suspects and accused.
Expertise allows to establish important information about the identity of criminals in non-obvious crimes.
Forensic examinations are an important means of proving the guilt or innocence of suspects and accused persons. They allow establishing circumstances that contribute to the commission of crimes.
In order to create the most favorable conditions for the production of forensic examinations and to facilitate the work of the investigator in finding the necessary expert institution, in Russia the production of examinations is organized according to the departmental principle, meaning that most expert institutions are located in the same department in which the investigative units are located.
At present
The forensic science units of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation are a system of forensic science units consisting of four levels. The first level includes forensic science units of the lower level of internal affairs agencies — city and district departments.
Here, the simplest examinations are carried out: fingerprinting, trace evidence, examination of bladed weapons.
In addition to expert examinations, employees at this level perform a significant amount of work to ensure the participation of specialists in investigative actions, operational-search activities, maintaining fingerprint files and auxiliary fingerprint files.
In addition to experts, forensic technicians who perform work not related to the production of expert examinations also work in forensic science units at this level.
The second level includes forensic departments (divisions) of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, Main Directorate of Internal Affairs, and Department of Internal Affairs. They form the basis of the forensic service. It is here that most of the examinations carried out in the internal affairs agencies are carried out. The following examinations are carried out at this level.
Author's examination.
It establishes whether the author of the given text is a specific person; whether the author of several texts is one person; what are the characteristic data of the author of the text (native language, literacy level, profession). The total volume of samples submitted for examination must be at least 20 — 25 sheets.
Ballistic examination.
The objects of this examination are items similar to weapons, firearms, ammunition (bullets, cartridges, buckshot, shot, wads).
The examination resolves the following issues:
whether the item is a firearm, where, when (manufacturer, firm, year of manufacture) the weapon was manufactured; whether the weapon is fit for firing; whether the weapon has been repaired; whether it is possible to fire the weapon without pulling the trigger; what are the ballistic characteristics of the weapon; whether the weapon has been fired since its last cleaning; what is the original content of the markings (sawed off, hammered in) on the weapon.
When examining ammunition, a ballistic examination decides:
what type (type, sample) do the presented cartridges belong to; what kind of weapon are they intended for firing; are the cartridges suitable for firing; where and when were the cartridges (casings) manufactured; were the cartridges (their elements) manufactured using materials or tools seized from a specific person.
A wide range of issues is resolved by ballistic examination in relation to gunshot residue:
What type of weapon was used to fire the bullet (casing); Were the presented bullets (casings) fired from the same weapon; Was the bullet (casing) fired from the presented weapon; Did the bullet and casing submitted for examination constitute a single cartridge before the shot? Is the damage to the affected object a firearm? What type of weapon was used to fire a shot, what type of projectile caused the firearm damage; How many shots were used to cause the firearm damage: What could have been the relative positions of the victim and the shooter, the victim’s pose; From what distance was the shot fired; From what distance was the shot fired; How long ago was the shot fired.
In addition to the weapon, bullets, casings, and cartridges, the crime scene inspection report, autopsy report, and the victim’s clothing are sent for examination. All objects must be packed in such a way as to exclude any possibility of outside influence.
Portrait examination.
The objects of its study are photographs of people.
The following questions are usually put to the resolution of a portrait examination:
one or different faces are depicted in the photographs; one or different faces are depicted in photographs of a living person and a corpse; one or different faces are depicted in film and video frames.
Original photographs must be sent to the portrait examination, and only in their absence — copies.
The persons depicted in the photographs must be approximately the same age and photographed from the same angle and at approximately the same time. It is desirable that the photographs be normal in terms of contrast, without defects. The photographs are signed on the back and certified by the signature of the investigator and the seal of the institution.
Handwriting examination.
It establishes the author of the handwritten text and signature, determines the gender and age of the writer and the circumstances of the handwritten texts.
The following questions are usually put to the resolution of this examination:
by which of the specified persons the handwritten texts, letter and digital records were made, by whom the signature was made on behalf of the given person, by him or herself or by someone else, whether the handwritten texts (signatures) in several documents were made by the same person; what gender was the person who made the handwritten text; what age group does the author of the handwritten text belong to, whether the text was made under unusual conditions; whether the text was made in a deliberately changed handwriting; whether the text (signature) was made in imitation of a specific person; whether the text was made with the left hand, if the author’s usual writing hand is the right hand; whether the text was made in an unusual psychophysiological state (during illness, while drunk, at a low temperature, etc.).
Documents are presented for examination in the original, and in the case of writing on the wall, it is permissible to present photographs of the texts. Together with documents — material evidence — samples (free or experimental) in the amount of 5 — 10 pages of free text and 15-20 experimental samples of the signature are presented.
Technical and forensic examination of documents.
The objects of this examination are: identity documents, banknotes, securities, educational certificates, diplomas, and other documents granting any rights.
When examining these documents, two groups of questions are resolved — recognition and identification.
The first group includes questions on establishing the method of document production, the presence of changes in the document, identifying illegible texts, reading crossed out or blacked out texts, determining the age of the document, and some others.
The second group includes questions on the identification of seal and stamp impressions, typewritten text, printed products and a number of others.
Forensic examination of documents is often complex, since it uses not only forensic methods, but also methods of physics, chemistry, printing, and materials science.
With regard to establishing the method of production of documents, writing tools and means, the following questions are most often asked before the examination:
what method is used to produce the document form (banknote, security) — printing, photographic, electrographic, thermographic:
what method are the printing forms made (manual engraving, photomechanical, typesetting);
what class, type, brand, model does the typewriter belong to, on which the text of the document is printed;
what kind of coloring agent was used in the execution of the document details;
what type of document paper is it;
what type of binding material is it used to produce the document; what type of glue was used to produce the document;
was the banknote (document form) manufactured by Goznak.
When establishing the method of changing documents, the following questions are resolved:
whether the document has been subject to any changes (erasures, etching, additions, reprinting), if so, how were they made and what was its original content;
were any parts of the document replaced;
was the photograph replaced;
was the original change to the document made by pasting in individual fragments;
what is the content of filled-in (crossed-out, painted over) texts;
what is the content of faded texts;
what is the content of the burned documents;
what is the content of the indented texts;
what was done first, the text of the document or the imprint of the seal intersecting with the strokes, etc.
In the case of identification studies, the following questions may be asked before the examination: was the text printed on this typewriter;
was the imprint made by this seal;
whether the document form was printed from this printing plate;
whether the document was produced on this
duplicating machine;
whether this set of writing instruments was used to produce the document;
whether the parts of the document and some others previously formed a single whole.
When appointing an examination on technical and forensic examination of documents, the recommendations for their preparation, set out in any textbook on forensic science and special manuals, must be strictly observed.
Traceological examination.
The objects of this examination are fingerprints, footprints and shoe prints, teeth marks, animal footprints (hoofprints), traces of burglary tools and instruments, traces of vehicles, locks and locking devices, seals and twists, mass-produced items of knots and loops.
When sending for fingerprint examination, the following questions may be asked: are there fingerprints on the presented objects, if so, are they suitable for identification, were the fingerprints left by a specific person; were the fingerprints taken during inspection of several crime scenes left by the same person; with which hand and which finger were the fingerprints left; what features were reflected in the fingerprints of the person (scars, calluses, deformations of fingers, bandages, etc.).
If there are footprints, the examination will determine: what type of footwear left the footprints (boots, shoes, sports shoes, etc.); what is the height of the person who left the footprint; what are the anatomical features of the person whose footprints were found at the scene; whether the footprints were left by footwear confiscated from a specific person; whether the footwear found at the scene was worn by a specific person, etc.
Based on the teeth marks, the examination can determine: whether the marks on the given object were left by the teeth of a person, an animal or something else; what are the anatomical features of the dental apparatus of the person who left the marks; whether the teeth marks on the presented object were left by this person.
If the marks were left by animals, the examination can establish what animal left the marks, whether the marks were left by this animal, whether the footprints (horseshoes, hooves) were left by the same animal or by different ones.
When examining traces of burglary tools and instruments, the expert decides: from which side the damage was caused; what is the mechanism by which the traces were formed; what type or kind is the tool or instrument that left the traces; whether the traces were formed by one or more instruments; whether the traces on different objects were formed by the same instrument (instrument); whether the traces were formed by the instrument presented for examination.
Based on the vehicle tracks, the examination establishes: what type and model of vehicle, what parts of it left the tracks, whether the tracks were left by one or more vehicles, in what direction the vehicle was moving, whether the tracks were left by this vehicle, whether the discovered object is part of this vehicle, what was the relative position of the vehicles at the time of the collision.
When examining locks and locking devices, trace examination can establish whether the lock mechanism has been repaired, whether there are traces left by a foreign object on the lock, whether the lock can be opened with a master key, whether the traces on the lock were left by this tool, etc.
When examining seals and screws, the examination can answer whether the seal has been opened and in what way, whether it is possible to extract the wiring from the seal body without leaving traces, what is the content of the digital and letter imprints on the seal, whether the seal was crimped with the sealing vices provided, whether the screw was unscrewed and re-screwed.
When examining a whole by its parts, it is established: what object is a part of, whether these objects previously constituted a single whole, whether the given object was divided into parts by a specific object.
When examining mass-market products, the question is usually decided whether the products or semi-finished products seized from a specific person were manufactured on a specific machine or using specific parts, molds, matrices, etc.; whether the product found at the scene of the crime and seized from the suspect were manufactured on the same device.
When examining knots and loops, trace evidence determines what type the knots and loops are, whether the knots and loops are professional, and if so, what profession they are typical of.
If traces of clothing are sent for examination, the most common questions asked before the examination are: were the traces left by areas of clothing of a specific person; what is the mechanism of formation of damage to clothing; what type of tool caused the damage to clothing; were the damage to clothing caused by this specific item.
Phonoscopic examinations.
There are two directions in the production of this examination: technical examination of phonograms and examination of speech information recorded on it.
During technical examination of phonograms, tape recorders, dictaphones, microphones, magnetic tapes, video recorders, and cassettes for them are diagnosed. These issues are resolved based on the amplitude-frequency characteristics displayed on phonograms and complexes of tracks appearing on the magnetic tape as it passes through the tape transport mechanism and the magnetic heads of the sound recording device.
When examining sound information, the speaker is identified, regarding whom the following can be established: gender, age, nationality, profession, area of long-term residence, nature and level of education, mental and physical condition, presence of certain diseases, absence of front teeth and other issues.
The completeness of the extracted information largely depends on the content of the individualizing features of the speaker, displayed on the magnetic medium.
Regarding oral speech, the following questions can be put to the phonoscopic examination:
does the speech on the presented phonogram belong to a specific person, whose speech samples are presented on such and such a cassette; was the text (the content of the text is indicated verbatim) recorded on cassette No. 1 and the text (the verbatim content is indicated) recorded on cassette No. 2 pronounced by one or different persons; how many persons took part in the conversation recorded on the phonogram of cassette No. 1; what personal characteristics does the person have, whose speech is presented on the phonogram of the attached cassette.
If a noisy phonogram is sent for examination, the expert is asked the following questions:
is it possible to establish the verbatim content of the conversation on the presented phonogram; is the oral speech recorded on the phonogram spontaneous, a reproduction of something learned by heart, or a reading of a written text.
This examination also establishes:
whether the presented phonogram shows signs of a break in the continuity of the recording, editing or any changes made during the recording process or after its completion; whether the presented phonogram is an original or a copy, and if it is a copy, which one — first, second, etc.; whether the recording was made on the presented recording device; whether the recording was made on the same or different tape recorders.
Phototechnical examination.
The objects of this examination are film and photo cameras, photographic enlargers, framing frames, cutters, shooting conditions and processing of photographic materials and some others.
The following questions are most often put to the examination for resolution:
whether the presented film (negatives) was exposed with the given camera; whether the presented photographs were made with the given enlarger; whether the given glossing agent was used to glaze the given prints; whether the presented positives were obtained from the given negatives; what are the actual dimensions of the object depicted in the photograph; what is the distance between the objects captured in the photograph; what kind of camera was used to make the given photograph; was retouching used in making the given photograph; was photomontage used in making the given photograph; whether the presented prints (negatives) were made on photographic paper (film) of the same kind; what processing solutions were used in making the given photograph.
Forensic examination of materials, substances and products.
The objects of this examination are paints and varnishes, petroleum products, fuels and lubricants, fibers of various origins, gunshot products, glass and glass products, metals and metal products, narcotics and potent substances, forensic marker substances.
Both forensic and physical-chemical methods are used in the study of these objects.
When sending paints and varnishes, petroleum products, fuels and lubricants for examination, the following questions are asked:
is the presented substance an oil product and, if so, to what group, brand of product does it belong and what is its main purpose; does the liquid submitted for examination belong to the group of flammable liquids; do the presented sample and the comparison sample have the same source of origin; what brand does the presented gasoline sample correspond to; does the gasoline contain impurities of other oil products (kerosene, diesel fuel) or other liquids (water).
When examining glass and glass products, the following questions are addressed:
whether the object submitted for examination is glass, and if so, what kind or type of glass does it belong to; whether the object submitted for examination is a fragment of a headlight lens, and if so, on what vehicle could it have been installed; whether the glass fragments found at the scene of the accident and those removed from the vehicle have a single source of origin.
When examining metals, alloys and products made from them, the examination establishes:
what metal (alloy) is the item submitted for examination made of; is the metal submitted for examination precious, if so, what is the quantitative content of its components, do metal products have a single source of origin; do the metal particles of the product (object, item) submitted for examination belong to; are there traces of metallization on the submitted object, if so, what could be the source of their origin; is the coin submitted for examination counterfeit, if so, what metal is it made of; has the marking on the object been altered.
When examining polymeric materials, the following questions are addressed:
— is this substance a polymer, if so, what kind, type, grade does it belong to;
— do the samples of polymer products have a single source of origin;
— is the mark on the asphalt (clothing) formed by rubber particles, if so, what is the type, type, grade of this rubber;
— what adhesive material was used to glue this object;
— was the photograph on the document re-glued.
When examining narcotic substances, the examination determines:
— whether the substance presented for examination is a narcotic (potent) substance;
— whether there are traces of narcotic drugs or potent substances on the items seized from the suspect;
— whether the seized narcotic drugs (potent substances) could have been manufactured at a specific enterprise;
— what is the quantity of the narcotic drug.
When examining special chemical substances of forensic markers, the question is decided whether the coloring substance found on the hair, skin, clothing of the suspect, crime instruments, and other objects belonging to the suspect is homogeneous in morphological and chemical composition with the substances seized at the scene of the crime and presented as samples for comparative examination.
Examination of bladed weapons.
The objects of its study are: bladed weapons, their individual parts, weapon blanks, items with traces of bladed weapons.
The following questions are most often asked before this examination:
— does the presented item belong to bladed weapons;
— what type of bladed weapons it belongs to;
— by what method (industrial, homemade) was the presented item made;
— whether a trace was left on the presented object by a cold weapon seized from the suspect.
In order to provide more effective assistance to investigative units in investigating crimes, in addition to forensic examinations, the forensic units of the internal affairs agencies have organized the production of a number of other examinations, in the production of which research methods of other sciences not related to forensic science are used.
This is an automotive technical examination, biological examination of tissues and secretions of humans and animals, botanical examination, explosive-technical, mineralogical (gemological), fire-technical, soil science, facial reconstruction from the skull, examination of food products.
Automotive technical examination is carried out on road traffic accidents (RTA) in order to establish the technical condition of the vehicle, the mechanism of the RTA and other circumstances related to the RTA.
The following questions are usually asked during this examination:
— is the vehicle in good working order, if not, what is the malfunction;
— could the existing malfunction have influenced the accident and how;
— when did the technical malfunction occur (before the accident, at the time of its occurrence or after it);
— whether the original marking of the vehicle parts (units) has been changed, if so, what was its original content;
— what was the mechanism of the accident;
— did the driver have the technical ability to prevent the accident;
— what technical means (type, brand) left the traces found at the scene of the accident;
— are the particles removed during the inspection of the scene of the accident (car) particles of the paintwork of the vehicle, if so, is it possible to determine the color of this vehicle, its type, whether it has been repainted, how many times;
— are the glass (plastic) fragments parts of the diffuser, on which vehicles is it installed;
— are there any traces on the presented technical means characteristic of an accident;
— what is the mechanism of formation of these traces.
The following are submitted for examination: a resolution on the appointment of an examination, a criminal case, a vehicle, units and assemblies, traces of a vehicle, glass fragments (plastic), diagrams of damage to the victim.
Biological examination of human and animal tissues and secretions examines blood, sperm, saliva, sweat, hair, and tissue particles.
This examination resolves the following questions:
— are there traces of blood, sperm, sweat, urine, or odor on the presented objects;
— what is their group affiliation;
— does the blood belong to a human or an animal;
-what is the sex of the blood;
-does the blood come from a specific person;
-can these father and mother be the child's parents (in case of theft, substitution of children);
-did the pregnancy occur from the suspect in rape (the issue can only be resolved by examining the fetus during termination of pregnancy);
-did the smell extracted from the blood stain come from a specific person;
— did the blood traces come from a living person or from a corpse;
— did the sperm traces come from several men and could they have been specific individuals;
— did the smell on a cigarette butt (cigar), telephone receiver, knife handle, etc. come from a specific person;
— what is the group affiliation of the fingerprints (lips) according to the ABO system;
— whether they were left by a specific person, what is the gender of these traces.
When sending hair for examination, the following questions may be asked:
— whether the presented objects are human hair;
— what is the mechanism of hair separation (fell out, cut, pulled out), what is the regional origin of the hair (from what part of the body did it come);
— whether the hair was subjected to any impacts (mechanical damage, cosmetic treatment);
— are there any signs of hair disease on the presented hair;
— what is the group (according to the ABO system) and gender of the hair (decided in the presence of a hair follicle);
— how long ago was the hair cut, dyed, or bleached.
When sending fragments of muscles, bones and other tissues for examination, the examination can establish whether these objects originated from a person or an animal; whether their blood group matches the blood group of a specific person; whether parts of a dismembered corpse belong to one person.
When examining animal tissue, the examination establishes whether the presented tissue belongs to an animal and which one; similar questions are resolved when sending hair for examination.
Botanical examination.
The objects of this examination are plants and their parts (roots, leaves, stems, seeds, bark, wood, fibers, as well as sawdust, hay, straw, tobacco, tobacco products, plants containing narcotic substances, etc.).
This examination resolves the following issues:
— are there particles of plant origin on the carrier objects and, if so, what is their nature;
— do the plant particles seized from the scene of the crime and found on the suspect's belongings have a common generic affiliation;
— what form of poppy (opium, oil, ornamental, wild) does the plant seized from the suspect belong to;
— what is the component composition of the mixture of plant objects submitted for examination.
Explosive-technical examination.
This examination resolves the following questions:
— is the presented substance explosive, if so, what kind;
— whether the explosive was manufactured industrially or homemade;
— whether the presented device contains an explosive;
— whether the item presented for examination is an explosive device, whether it was manufactured industrially or homemade.
When examining traces of an explosion, it is established:
— whether there was an explosion of an explosive, if so, which one, what is its purpose and area of application;
-what are the destructive properties of the exploded device;
-if a homemade device was exploded, what kind of industrial explosive device was it an analogue of?
The following are submitted for explosive-technical examination: devices and substances that are assumed to be explosive objects, objects of the environment with traces of an explosion, soil and samples of the substance taken from the places of the greatest destruction, scrapings and washings from the places of the greatest contamination, drawings, diagrams, blueprints made by the suspect, possible samples for comparative examination, a protocol of inspection of the scene of the incident, photo tables, video recordings, protocols of interrogation of eyewitnesses, conclusions of other examinations that contain any data for explosive-technical examination.
Mineralogical examination.
The objects of this examination are natural and semi-natural stones, their synthetic analogues and imitations, ornamental stones, rocks and products made from them.
The experts are usually asked the following questions:
-what are the names of the stones submitted for examination;
-are the submitted stones natural, synthetic or imitations;
-are the submitted stones precious, semi-precious or ornamental;
-what is the weight and size of the stones;
-are there any marks on the surface of the stones.
Fire-technical examination — is conducted in order to establish the location of the fire, the causes and other circumstances of its occurrence and development.
In relation to establishing the source of the fire and the characteristics of the development of the fire, this examination asks the following questions:
— what area of the area (premises) was the source of the fire, how many sources of fire were there;
— what is the path of fire spread;
— what conditions contributed to the development of the fire;
— what explains the flashes, sounds, intense smoke emission and other phenomena observed during the fire;
— what is the duration of the flaming combustion, smoldering of this material;
— could the fire have occurred from the spontaneous combustion of these substances or materials;
— could the fire have occurred from an electrical short circuit, from a lightning strike;
— whether the fire was caused by deliberate arson, etc.
Items with traces of flammable and lubricating substances, sections of electrical wires with traces of melting of electrical protection devices (fuses, circuit breakers), electric heating devices together with electrical cords, items with signs of technical impact, samples of flammable materials for comparative study are submitted for examination.
The criminal case is also submitted to the expert.
Soil science examination — is conducted in order to establish the presence of a certain person in a specific area.
The examination asks the following questions:
— are there soil deposits on the presented clothing, footwear or other items;
— what is the mechanism of formation of soil deposits;
— what is the source of origin of the soil;
— do the soil deposits on the suspect's clothing and the soil samples from the crime scene have a common generic (group) affiliation;
— how long ago did the soil deposits form on the carrier object?
For comparative testing, three to four samples of 50-200 g are sent for examination. Control samples are taken at a distance of 25-50 m from the place where the comparative samples are taken (control samples are taken in mutually perpendicular directions from the place where the comparative samples are taken). Soil samples are packed in paper bags.
It is not recommended to use glass containers or plastic bags for packing soil.
Facial reconstruction based on the skull.
The purpose of reconstruction is to obtain diagnostic data on the features of the appearance of the deceased (deceased) from the skull in the event of the absence or putrefactive change of soft tissues on the face. Reconstruction is performed only in the absence of a version about the identity of the presumed deceased.
When examining the skull and skeletal bones, data is established on gender, age, racial type, condition of the dental apparatus, congenital and pathological changes and individual characteristics.
Based on the results of the skull examination, a certificate is drawn up outlining the established data, to which a photograph of the reconstruction is attached.
Reconstruction materials are used in the verification of the missing persons register, as well as for demonstration on television and publication in the press.
If among the missing persons citizens similar to the reconstructed external appearance of the skeletonized corpse are identified, on the basis of the investigator's decision, an examination is conducted in the Expert-Criminalistic Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation for the purpose of identifying the person.
Along with the decision, the expert is provided with detailed personal data (surname, first name, patronymic, date of birth, nationality, place of residence, circumstances of disappearance), anthropological data (height, build, eye color, hair, skin, headwear, outerwear and shoe sizes), multi-angle lifetime photographs from recent years, original medical documents (medical histories, outpatient and dental records, radiographs, blood type information).
The conclusion about whether a skull belongs to a specific missing person is made on the basis of a comparative analysis of all available data. It can be categorically positive, categorically negative, presumably positive or negative.
Food product examinationis carried out in order to establish the name, grade of food products, their compliance with GOSTs, MRTU, RTU, compliance with the standards for the introduction of raw materials into the product and production technology, establishing the fact and method of falsification of food products, as well as determining the concentration of nitrates and pesticides.
The objects of this examination are: meat and meat products, milk and dairy products, bakery, confectionery products, edible fats and oils, alcoholic beverages, low-alcohol and soft drinks, culinary products and drinks, fish and fish products, flavorings (adjika, pepper seasoning, etc.).
The range of issues resolved by the examination is very broad and depends on the type of product and the tasks facing the investigation.
Thus, when examining meat and meat products, the examination determines what animal it belongs to (beef, pork, lamb), what is the ratio of meat and breading in semi-finished products, whether the content of filler (bread, porridge) in chopped semi-finished products corresponds, what is the moisture content of minced meat products, whether the chemical indicators of the sausage submitted for examination correspond to the requirements of the standard for sausage of this name, whether the raw materials specified in the recipe were used in the manufacture of sausage.
When examining milk and dairy products, the examination decides: whether the given product meets the requirements of the standard, what is the fat content of milk and dairy products, whether milk is diluted with water, whether soda, starch, flour or other impurities are added to milk, whether sour cream is diluted with milk, kefir, cottage cheese, what is the sugar and fat content in sweet cheese curds, whether ice cream corresponds to its name.
When examining bakery products, the examination establishes: whether the product complies with the standard, what is the content of dry matter, fat, sugar in the confectionery product, whether the standards for adding eggs to the confectionery product are met, what kind of oil (sunflower, butter) was used in the production of the confectionery product, whether the cream is made on the basis of butter or margarine.
When examining honey, the examination establishes whether it is natural or artificial, whether the honey contains foreign impurities (sugar, starch, molasses, etc.), what is the botanical origin of the honey (linden, buckwheat, etc.).
When examining edible fats and oils, the examination decides: what is the substance received for examination, whether the fat or oil submitted for examination corresponds to its name, whether the sample submitted for examination is butter, whether there are foreign impurities (flour, starch) in the butter.
During the expert examination of alcoholic beverages, it is determined: whether beer, vodka, cognac meet the requirements of the standard (fullness of filling, alcohol content, sugar, titratable acidity), whether wine, vodka, cognac corresponds to the name indicated on the label, whether wine, vodka, cognac is diluted with water or another liquid, what alcohol is used to make the vodka, whether the wine presented for examination is factory-made or home-made, whether the presented liquid is alcohol, and if alcohol, then what kind.
When examining low-alcohol and non-alcoholic beverages, the examination establishes whether the juice and beer submitted for examination comply with the standard requirements, whether the juice and beer are diluted with water, whether the submitted juice is natural, and if not, whether citric acid, sugar, or dyes were used in its preparation, and what raw materials were used in the preparation of the juice.
When examining culinary products (ready meals), the examination can establish: whether the yield of the dishes meets the recipe requirements, whether the completeness of the raw material (meat, fish) content meets the standards provided for by the recipe, whether the weight of pies, belyashi and their filling meet the yield standards according to the layout, whether the fat, sugar, milk, eggs are fully included in the culinary product, butter or margarine is used in the manufacture of the product, from what meat (beef, pork, lamb, etc.) the mince is made, whether the coffee submitted for examination meets the recipe requirements for the completeness of the coffee, sugar, milk content.
When examining fish and fish products, it is established: whether sturgeon black caviar is natural or artificial, whether the caviar is made in a factory or at home, whether the caviar submitted for examination meets the requirements of the standard.
When examining flavorings, it is established whether the product under examination complies with the established requirements, whether the presented product contains foreign impurities, etc.
It is advisable to select samples for expert examination with the participation of a specialist or at least after careful consultation with him.
Recently, the network of existing laboratories has been significantly expanded in forensic departments and new laboratories have begun to be created, expanding the possibilities for providing assistance to investigative agencies and inquiry bodies.
These include forensic medical examinations, which examine traces of biological origin in a broad aspect and perform facial reconstruction based on the skull.
The above are the examinations that are performed in the forensic export units of the internal affairs agencies.
Basically, the same examinations are performed in the forensic institutions of the Ministry of Justice.
5 PROSPECTS FOR TECHNICAL AND FORENSIC SUPPORT FOR INVESTIGATION
5.1 Prospects for the introduction of computer technology
Speaking about the prospects for the introduction of technical and forensic tools into investigations, it can be confidently predicted that they will, first of all, be associated with the introduction of computer technology.
This conclusion can be made on the basis of the serious organizational measures currently being carried out.
Thus, the Investigative Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation has created a special department as part of the information and analytical department, the main task of which is to organize the introduction of computer technology into the activities of investigative apparatuses of internal affairs agencies that investigate the overwhelming majority of crimes.
The measures taken by this department allow us to judge the directions in which computers will be introduced into investigative work.
They boil down to the following:
-
automation of methods for investigating certain types of crimes;
-
establishing effective control over the investigation;
-
organizing automated exchange of regulatory and legal information;
-
maintaining automated information systems for investigation;
-
creating automated workstations for the investigator and the head of the investigative unit.
By now, the following investigation methods have been developed and successfully tested:
-
crimes in the field of computer information;
-
crimes related to illegal drug trafficking;
-
attacks on cultural property;
-
robberies and robberies committed with the purpose of seizing citizens' property;
-
home thefts;
-
banditry;
-
criminal fires.
Serious work is being done to computerize the investigative units of the internal affairs agencies.
A concept for the creation of a «Specialized territorially distributed automated system of the Investigative Committee and investigative units of the internal affairs agencies» (STRAS-SK-SU-SO) has been developed and is being partially implemented.
Within the framework of this concept, a local computer network has been created in the Investigative Committee, including 103 workstations, and e-mail has been introduced for information interaction with the investigative departments of the Ministry of Internal Affairs-UVD.
Work is underway to computerize the investigative departments of the Ministry of Internal Affairs-UVD, as well as the investigative departments of the City Department of Internal Affairs, based on the creation of computer networks in them.
The concept of creating the STRAS of the investigative departments of the Ministry of Internal Affairs-UVD, investigative departments of the District Department of Internal Affairs provides for the solution of the following tasks.
With regard to investigative departments under the Ministry of Internal Affairs-UVD:
1) creation of local computing stations providing communication with local computing stations and information centers, communication with the Investigative Committee under the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, communication with investigative departments of the ROVD, access to the reference system of the administration of the President of the Russian Federation;
2) organization of legal reference systems;
3) effective use of automated methods of investigating crimes (so far for six types of crimes);
4) effective use of records of information centers: preventive, wanted persons, weapons search, car search, records of criminals by nicknames;
5) quick reference of telephone-address, references on organizations. Here there will also be addresses and telephone numbers of investigative departments of the Ministry of Internal Affairs-UVD and telephone numbers of the personnel of the Investigative Committee
under the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation;
6) prompt receipt of information on the crime situation in the region (access to information center data);
7) receipt of information on the work of the investigative units of the Investigative Department under the Ministry of Internal Affairs-UVD and investigative departments of the ROVD at any time;
8) solution of organizational and managerial tasks based on the analysis of data stored in the computer on the positive work of investigators, business trips, movement of control and observation cases, letters and appeals of citizens.
As applied to investigative departments of the ROVD, the STRAS system provides for the creation of legal reference and information systems, the possibility of using automated methods of investigating crimes, access to records of information centers, the organization of effective control over the investigation of criminal cases, and the maintenance of the necessary reference information.
Serious work is being carried out to introduce computer technology into the activities of forensic science units.
Automated systems are already actively used in the preparation of subjective portraits, fingerprinting, explosive-technical examinations, weapons examinations, trace examinations, fire-technical and auto-technical examinations, and identification of people by voice.
The Forensic Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation is currently providing its units with new programs:
• automated expert's place (ARM-EK) — a multifunctional software package that allows solving problems of analysis and processing of images of various forensic objects;
• an automated program for compiling subjective portraits and storing a database of wanted persons, allowing searching for information by a full or partial set of characteristics;
• an information retrieval system for determining the conformity of the chemical composition of a metal alloy with its GOST;
• a method for quantitative emission spectral analysis of the elemental composition of drugs of plant origin;
• an information system on firearms;
• an automated registration log of placing objects in a bullet-case library and access to it;
• a method for determining the grade of paper by its physicochemical composition;
• an automated system that allows comparing photographic images for the purpose of their identification;
• an automated atlas of the spectra of toxic and potent substances and some others.
Several new automated methods are being tested.
5.2 Prospects for the introduction of more advanced recording tools
Prospects for the introduction of color photography.
Various recording tools are used in forensic practice: cameras, video cameras, tape recorders and video recorders, adhesive films, impression materials, and others.
With the invention of color photography, serious organizational measures were taken to introduce it into investigative and expert activities.
Currently, color photography as a means of recording forensic objects is rarely used.
However, in the coming years the situation may change for the better.
Already now, some agencies practice using commercial photo studios equipped with the most modern equipment and branded reagents to process color photographic materials and make photographs.
Using the capabilities of commercial photo studios undoubtedly opens up wide opportunities for investigators to use color photography — this modern means of recording — in the investigation of criminal cases.
Digital photography is a promising means of recording. It has significant advantages over conventional photography.
Unlike conventional photography, where the image is perceived by a light-sensitive layer of photographic film, in digital photography the role of the light receiver is performed by a special matrix, from which the image is then input into the computer.
Considering the current widespread use of personal computers, digital photography has great prospects.
Currently, many foreign companies are working on the development of digital cameras.
Publications have appeared that talk about the use of digital cameras in forensic practice. In our country, a great deal of work on studying the possibilities of using digital photography equipment is being done by E.N. Dmitriev, an employee of the Expert-Criminalistics Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation.
He analyzed in detail the technical characteristics of the digital cameras being produced and determined which of them are best suited for use in investigative actions and expert examinations.
He designed an investigative suitcase with digital photography equipment (Fig. 38).
E.N. Dmitriev developed a number of recommendations on the use of digital photography during crime scene inspection, identification, forensic examinations, and forensic records management, tested them in the Forensic Science Center, a number of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Department of Internal Affairs, and successfully defended his PhD dissertation.
Fig. 38. Investigative suitcase:
1 — personal computer;
2 — color inkjet printer;
3 — digital camera;
4 — photo flash;
5 — network adapter;
6 — interchangeable lens,
7 — «mouse»
5.3 Prospects for expanding the arsenal of technical and forensic tools
In the coming years, polygraphs will obviously be introduced into investigative practice — devices that react to the stress state of the body.
The main purpose of these devices is to record the reaction of the human body to questions asked of it.
Polygraphs record the activity of the cardiovascular system, respiration, and electrical resistance of the skin (galvanic skin reflex).
If the subject gives false testimony on the polygraph, the device records increased heart rate, changes in breathing, increased blood pressure and skin temperature, and some other symptoms. That is why the polygraph is often called a «lie detector».
Currently, the internal affairs agencies have polygraphs not only of American manufacture, but also those produced by domestic companies: ZAO EPOS Group, TOO Geolid (polygraph Barrier 14/897), AOZT Inex-Polygraph (polygraph RM-004), TOO Grotek (polygraph MCP 2611).
It is appropriate to note that the domestic polygraph «EPOS-5» (Fig. 39), unlike foreign polygraphs, allows one to determine the physical condition of the subject before questioning, which is of great importance, and its cost is more than half that of the American one.
The polygraph «EPOS-5» provides input, automated analysis and reproduction on the monitor screen of the following physiological signals: upper respiration, lower respiration, galvanic skin response, pulse rate, blood pressure.
The polygraph allows you to assess the degree of correctness of answers to questions, identify hidden information, determine the involvement of the subject in the event under investigation with an accuracy of up to 97%.
Fig. 39 Computer polygraph «Epos-5»
It can be used in both stationary and mobile versions, and the polygraph operator does not necessarily have to have a medical education.
In 1997, this polygraph was demonstrated at the 10th International Salon «Milipol-97» in Paris and received high praise from foreign specialists.
Currently, opportunities are being created to check all fingerprints from unsolved crimes across the entire array of fingerprint cards.
The automated fingerprint information system (ADIS) «Papillon» is already being implemented.
It allows processing fingerprint cards in a fully automatic mode. Centers, deltas, flexor folds, pattern types, small details are determined without any operator intervention.
It is very important that when entering information into the computer memory, fingerprint cards are not pre-selected for quality.
The system has a high selectivity. When checking a trace with 15-17 features on an array of a million fingerprints, the number of false hints is on average about 15, and often there are none at all.
The internal affairs agencies of the Russian Federation already have about two hundred such systems. For the most part, these are large city and regional agencies, but in some regions — they are also used in regional forensic departments.
According to the developers of the system, in total, more than a million fingerprint cards have already been entered into the computer memory and more than 100 thousand fingerprints — over 10 thousand crimes have been solved using them.
Today, scanners for inkless fingerprinting are also being created and widely introduced into practice.
Inkless fingerprinting allows fingerprints to be entered directly into a computer and immediately used to verify traces.
Fingerprints obtained using the inkless method meet the highest requirements and today this technology is widely used.
The arsenal of technical and forensic tools will be expanded at the expense of traditional forensic equipment. Thus, four new models of mobile forensic laboratories have already been developed.
When the situation with funding of law enforcement agencies improves, serial production of many technical and forensic tools that are currently available in single copies or small batches (for example, search devices PDSP, «Kaima», «Konus», etc.) will be organized.
A number of new devices have been developed specifically for expert examinations.
First of all, the Regula device (model 4005) (Fig. 40) should be mentioned, which can be called a forensic combine for examining documents and money.
It allows examining documents in diffused light, in oblique, ultraviolet, infrared rays with tenfold magnification.
The device can detect magnetic pigments, metal threads, colored threads and fibers, read miniature fonts, relief printing, and see watermarks.
The device is equipped with a miniature video camera, which allows you to display an image on the screen. If desired, the manufacturer can supply the Regula with a special board that allows you to process the image on a computer.
Until recently, as is known, there were many complaints about the validity of expert opinions on the study of bladed weapons.
The situation may change significantly with the arrival of new products for the study of this type of weapon in forensic units — the «Target» products and the «Blade» device.
The «Target» product is designed to determine the damaging properties of cold (throwing) weapons. It is a set of plates simulating the skin, soft tissues and skeleton of the human chest. The product includes 10 plates each — equivalent to the skin and muscle tissue.
The plate can withstand 50 blows from a cold weapon.
The plates are placed in a detachable metal case and are replaced as they wear out. The damaging properties are assessed based on the depth of penetration of the test sample into the product (Fig. 41).
The «Blade» device is designed to conduct an examination to determine the impact load and record the contact spot that occurs when a cold weapon with impact-crushing action strikes.
A standard dynamometer is used to measure the impact load.
Impacts can be applied in both vertical and horizontal planes (Fig. 42).
Fig. 41 «Target» product for studying the damaging properties of bladed weapons
Fig. 42. The «Bludgeon» device for examining
cold weapons of impact-crushing action
LISTING OF REFERENCES
1 Selivanov N.A. Fundamentals of forensic technology: Ch. VIII //Selivanov N.A. Forensic science: Textbook. Moscow: Legal literature, 1984.
2 Belkin R.S. Course of Soviet forensic science: In III vol. Vol. I. Moscow, 1977. Pp. 219 — 220; Vol. III. M., 1979. P. 41 — 43.
3 Strogovich M.S. Course of Soviet criminal procedure. Moscow: Higher School of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the USSR, 1958.
4 Vinberg A.I. Forensic science. Introduction to science. Moscow: Higher School of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the USSR, 1962.
5 Kalmykov V.P. On the theoretical foundations of systematization of methods, techniques and means of Soviet forensic science. Moscow: Pravovedenie, 1965.
6 Ishchenko E.P. Classification of scientific and technical means used in preliminary investigation //Theory and practice of collecting evidentiary information by technical means during preliminary investigation: Coll. t. Kyiv, 1980. P. 32.
7 Skorchenko P.T. Forensic science. Technical and forensic support for crime investigation: Textbook for universities. Moscow: Bylina, 1999. 272 p.
8 Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation. Moscow: Elite Publishing House, 2004. 208 p.
9 Makarov I.V., Skoromnikov K.S. Videotape recording — a method of recording evidence //Proceedings of the Higher School of the USSR Ministry of Internal Affairs. Moscow, 1972.
10 Levi A.A. Issues of legal regulation of the use of scientific and technical means in criminal proceedings //Theory and practice of collecting evidentiary information by technical means: Coll. tr. Kyiv, 1980. Pp. 16 — 17.
11 On the police: the law of the Russian Federation //Russian police. Laws, instructions, decrees, provisions: Coll. M., 1993.
12 On forensic examination: the law of the Russian Federation. M.: Project, 1997.
13 On operational-search activities: the law of the Russian Federation of June 5, 1995, Collected Legislation of the Russian Federation. 1995. No. 33. Art. 3349.
14 Crime Investigation Issues: Reference Manual. Moscow: Spork, 1997. pp. 430 — 455, 595 — 625.
15 Zakatov A.A., Oropai Yu.N. Use of Scientific and Technical Means and Special Knowledge in Crime Investigation. Kyiv: RIO MVD of the Ukrainian SSR, 1980.
16 Korukhov Yu.G. Modern Possibilities of Forensic Expertise //Forensic Support for the Activities of the Criminal Police and Preliminary Investigation Bodies. Moscow: Novy Yurist, 1997. pp. 159 — 200.
17 Forensic Science: Textbook //Ed. by prof. N.P. Yablokov. Moscow: Bek, 1996.
18 Forensic examinations performed in internal affairs agencies: Reference manual //Ed. by I. N. Kozhevnikov, V. F. Statkus. Moscow: Forensic Science Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, 1992.
19 Forensic science: Textbook for universities //Ed. by R. S. Belkin. Moscow: Norma-Infra, 1999.
20 Obraztsov V. A. Forensic science: Lecture course. Moscow, 1996.
21 Klochkov V. V., Obraztsov V. A., Edzhubov L. G. Computers in the system of forensic technology in light of modern research //Problems and system of forensic science in light of modern research: Collection of works. M., 1988. Page 57.
22 Skorchenko P.T. General Provisions of Forensic Technology: Chapter 9 //Skorchenko P.T. Forensic Science: Textbook. M.: Jurist, 1995. Pages 109 — 126.
23 Skorchenko P.T. Technical and Forensic Trace-Forming Means //Skorchenko P.T. Forensic Science: Textbook. M.: Jurist, 1997. Pages 346 — 350.
24 Shumilin S.F. Forensic Expertise: Chapter 22 //Shumilin S.F. Investigator's Guide. M .: INFRA-M IPK «League of Reason», 1997.