Quickly deployable security systems.
Alexander Ivanovich Larin, Candidate of Technical Sciences
QUICKLY DEPLOYABLE SECURITY SYSTEMS
Source: Special Equipment magazine
The presented review does not in any way claim to fully cover the world market of rapidly deployable systems, however, I hope that this material will help to determine the development trends of this class of security equipment both on the domestic market and abroad.
The significant differences between rapidly deployable security systems, as a class, and traditional perimeter security systems are:
- short installation time of system elements on site (usually no more than 1.5 hours for a standard set of equipment);
- the ability to quickly change the location of sensors on the ground, and therefore the configuration of the controlled boundary (area) depending on changes in the situation;
- the ability to install on terrain that is not prepared in terms of engineering.
These differences determine that rapidly deployable systems are intended to warn of an intruder approaching an object or of his presence in a certain controlled area.
Therefore, such systems can be used both independently and together with traditional perimeter security systems.
This class of security equipment has been most developed in the USA and a number of European countries, where state programs for the creation of such equipment have been implemented for several decades.
For example, the state program MPASS (USA) provides support for the RFPI and TRSS programs, which use a set of unattended ground sensors ANGSQ-257, containing seismic, magnetic and IR detectors.
The MPASS program also develops a technique for combining data from distributed sensors and their collective use by network subscribers. The sensors will be integrated into the Sensor Array Management network, designed to solve the following problems: matching sensors, combining their data, transmitting data and visually assessing the situation.
Initially conceived as equipment for government security agencies, rapidly deployable systems are now enjoying increasing commercial success.
As of the end of 1999, such systems were sold in more than 50 countries worldwide.
1. Analysis of the composition of foreign rapidly deployable detection systems.
The TASS (Tactical Automated Security System) was adopted by the US Electronic System Center (ESC) in 1995.
The TASS system includes:
- tactical relocatable sensors;
- signaling devices with personal computers of portable (Laptop) and desktop (Desktop) type and hand-held monitors;
- hand-held thermal imaging sensors AN/PAS-19 from Hughes Defense Cummunications;
- AGEMA Infrared System Thermovision 6-24 UC tripod-mounted sensors capable of detecting people at distances of up to 1.5 km and vehicles at distances of up to 3 km or more;
- software, communications hardware, interfaces, and ancillary components.
TRW System Integration Group (USA) has supplied the US Air Force with 12 TASS systems (worth $47 million) for deployment in the Middle East. Based on field testing, the TASS system was estimated to increase personnel protection by 16 times. The company has been awarded contracts to continue the work for five years from 1997 for $495 million.
TASS includes: Mini Intrusion Defection System or Enhanced MIDS.
Developed by Qual-Tron (USA), which has manufactured hundreds of thousands of unattended ground sensors UGS.
The EMIDS system has the same form, layout and functionality as MIDS, but unlike the latter, it contains a frequency synthesizer that allows communication in preferred frequency ranges in any part of the globe (manufactured in hundreds of thousands, used in more than 50 countries). The weight of a complete EMIDS set is 5.5 kg.
It includes: seismic, magnetic, infrared active and passive sensors, as well as traps in the form of stretched wires.
The sensor signals after analog-to-digital conversion and coding are sent to a transmitter in the 138-153 MHz range with an output power of 1 W. The EMIDS system has an output via a personal computer to an interface with other communication channels — telephone and satellite (allowing signals to be received at all points on earth).
The system can interact with other existing CLASSIC or REMBASS/IREMBASS systems.
The developer claims that its system is 10 times cheaper than known analogues with the same functionality, with the exception of classifying violators, but a trained operator can distinguish between wheeled and tracked vehicles by comparing their signatures measured by different types of sensors.
MIDS/EMIDS systems may include the following sensors:
- Remote Observation and Conforming Sensor (RO/CS), developed by NVESD USA (Night Vision Electronic Sensors Directoral). The sensor enables visual identification of violations served by MIDS/EMIDS systems and consists of one or more television cameras operating in low-light conditions and camouflaged to match the surrounding environment, a transmitter buried 10 cm in the ground, and a base station. When one of the sensors detects movement of an intruder, the MIDS/EMIDS system sends a signal to the transmitting module of the RO/CS sensor, which turns on the power of the corresponding television camera, and the images formed are transmitted in real time during a specified time period. At the base station, a video recorder is turned on and the received images are observed on the monitor screen;
- a portable sensor with a reconfigurable signal transmission line PRLS (Portable Reconfigurable Line Sensor), manufactured by Racon (USA);
- an external AES sensor (Advanced Exterior Sensor), which combines visible and IR imaging sensors and low-power radar detection and tracking sensors. A typical configuration for using such sensors consists of four remote modules with sensors located at the corners of a square area of terrain with a side of 1 km. The processing module contains a tracking device that reduces the frequency of false alarms and increases the detection ability of the sensors. The AES sensor head is mounted on a tripod and rotates at a frequency of 360 0/s. Overall dimensions of the installation: height 80 cm, diameter 80 cm, weight 2.3 kg. It contains a matrix with 160×1 IR radiation detectors (3.4-5 μm) based on lead selenide. The matrix field of view is 3600 in the horizontal and 8.50 in the vertical planes. The matrix produces 21600×160 image elements per head rotation. In addition, the sensor head contains: a linear matrix with 512×96 visible radiation detectors and the same field of view as the IR detector matrix; a radar sensor with a central frequency of 17 GHz, an output power of less than 100 mW and a radiation beam with a solution of 30 in the horizontal and 110 in the vertical planes. The maximum range is 1500 m. The sensor is designed to detect a walking person at a distance of at least 500 m (in rain 300 m), a crawling person — 250 m (200 m), a moving vehicle — 1000 m (800 m).
Man-Portable Networked Sensor System.
The central control station of this system with a personal computer of the Laptop type controls portable sets of sensors (up to 3).
The kits can be installed on a light truck or an unmanned aerial vehicle.
A typical set of system sensors includes:
- a video camera with a varifocal lens and a thermal imaging camera;
- a laser rangefinder;
- a GPS receiver;
- azimuth and tilt sensors;
- a port for inputting acoustic data.
The elements included in the kit are connected to the radio network with automatic repeaters. Inputs for signals from external sensors such as IREMBASS or TRSS (Tactical Remote Sensor System) are provided.
The IREMBASS (Improved Remotely Monitored Battlefield Sensor System) system developed by L-3 COM (USA) consists of sensors (passive IR, magnetic, seismic, acoustic), as in the previous REMBASS system, but it is more compact and has less weight.
It includes an AN/PSQ-7 monitor/programmer and a lightweight radio transmitter with a nominal range of 15 km.
Covert Local Area Sensor System for Intruder Classification CLASSIC.
Manufacturer — division Racal Radio Ltd. of the well-known Racal concern (Great Britain). The system has been supplied to 36 countries since 1982.
In 1997, the company released a modernized system CLASSIC 2000, which was announced as a “ground sensor system for remote control of terrain, object surveillance, perimeter protection and route monitoring.”
Advanced modular design of the system, advanced technical solutions to the most important problems of this class of security equipment — minimization of weight and size characteristics and provision of autonomous modules with power supply, unconditional commercial success, all this requires a more detailed story about the stop on the features of the system design.
The system equipment is intended primarily for use by the army, paramilitary units, police and special services.
The CLASSIC 2000 system is characterized by rapid deployment, a simple user interface, and high information content.
The system is compatible with all previously released sensors, but its main elements are made programmable, which has reduced their size, weight and cost.
The main elements of the system are: RA4310 monitor (photo 1), RTA4311 repeater, TA4312 multifunctional sensor, TA4314 magnetic sensor with built-in converter.
Photo 1. RA4310 monitor of the CLASSIC 2000 system
To increase the flexibility of the system as a whole, all sensors, relays and monitors are programmed using Classic 2000 software.
The programs run in WindowsO on IBM-compatible PCs.
Sensors and repeaters can be programmed directly from a PC. The software allows for the improvement of signal processing algorithms.
Each system monitor measuring 9.5×16.6×6.3 cm and weighing 1 kg can receive input signals from 99 sensors in the 148…155 MHz range and programmable channel selection. Signals are input either directly or via 3 repeaters.
The RA4310 monitor stores databases in non-volatile memory, and the serial interface allows for the transmission of intrusion data for processing by software using a terrain map and various data processing programs.
The database of sensors and repeaters is loaded from an IBM-compatible PC using the Classic 2000 software and contains the following information: equipment type (repeater, sensor, etc.), confidence interval (from 1 to 24 hours), channel number, transmission frequency. The monitor is used not only to transmit information to the operator, but also to transmit software information to sensors and repeaters.
The main source of information in the system is the multifunctional sensor TA4312, which can work with the following types of converters:
- MA4320 geophone (photo 2);
- 455912 piezoelectric cable (photo 3);
- MA4323 IR detectors (short range up to 15 m), MA4321 (medium range up to 50 m), MA4322 (long range up to 100 m) (photo 4);
- contact sensors (break wires, pressure sensors, etc.).
Photo 2. Geophone MA4320
Photo 3. Piezoelectric cable 455912
Photo 4. MA4323 IR Detectors
The TA4312 sensor automatically detects the type of transducer when connected and has all the algorithms necessary to recognize the nature of seismic signals (from a geophone or piezoelectric cable): people or vehicles, tracked or wheeled, as well as the target azimuth.
The sensor has dimensions of 12x12x5.2 cm and a weight of 0.85 kg with batteries (8 “AA” batteries in the MA4330 block) and an inconspicuous pin antenna.
Racal Radio Ltd. also offers a special module for magnetic sensors with a built-in converter. In addition, other sensors can be used in the CLASSIC 2000 system: water level and radiation sensors, as well as various chemical sensors.
Features of converter operation.
Signals generated by the MA4320 geophone ensure recognition and classification of human and vehicle intrusion.
The operation of the geophone is significantly affected by the type of soil on which it is located. The difference in detection range for wet compacted soil and dry loose soil can be up to 100 m.
The multifunctional sensor allows the operator to adjust seismic sensitivity with several settings, and the algorithm has an adaptive threshold to reduce the level of false alarms caused, for example, by soil vibrations during rain.
The 455912 piezoelectric cable functions similarly to a geophone, but detection is performed along the entire length of the cable (the 455912 is a distributed sensor, while the MA4320 is a concentrated sensor). The cable transducer is available in lengths from 25 to 1000 m and provides a detection range of up to 50 m in favorable conditions.
The CLASSIC 2000 MA4321-4323 passive infrared sensors are sophisticated dual-beam pyrometers with high-precision optics. Their signals are processed using algorithms adapted to the soil type and use joint data processing to determine the correlation between two observation zones, while it is possible to determine the direction of intrusion.
All types of IR sensors are interchangeable, since they use the same interface cable.
The Unibeam single-beam laser detection system is a portable laser barrier designed for the protection of local objects and installation at checkpoints, manufactured by Blomme Automation (France).
Unibeam consists of a transmitter, a receiver and a 9V alkaline battery. All components are sealed in black anodized aluminum alloy housings and have universal mounting devices. The transmitter is a GaAs laser diode with an infrared filter, and the receiver is a silicon Pin diode also with an infrared filter. The transmitter and receiver can be separated by a distance of up to 100 m.
Continuous operation time is 10-15 hours, from a battery of dry lithium cells — 20-50 hours. The overall dimensions of each component are 104x56x23 mm, weight 160 g.
Autonomous, quickly deployable portable passive IR system from RDS (UK) is equipped with a 12 V battery, operates for 500 hours. The detection zone is 40×10 m (model 5000) and 20×20 m (model 2000).
Within the zone, the system reacts to movement and temperature changes interpreted as human intrusion. The first signal transmitted by the system reports the coordinates of the location of the violation, and the second informs about an attempt to intrude or damage the system.
Analysis of the composition of domestic rapidly deployable security equipment
According to the reduced installation time (up to 1.5 hours), the following domestic means can be classified as quickly deployable security systems:
- radio beam alarm systems «Vitim» (SS-84RLB) (Elektrokhimpribor) and the «Mobil-RL» system under development (NIKIRET);
- wire-wave detection device «Gazon» (NIKIRET);
- portable security means of the breakaway principle of action (Ros, Krab-1, etc.).
Radio beam quick-deployable security systems
The most well-known is the serially produced, rapidly deployable radio beam signaling system “Vitim”, which is designed to protect local areas, temporary locations of people or vehicles, communication nodes, helipads, control points with the transmission of information via radio channel about the fact and location of a violation of the protected boundary.
The system can be used for operational or stationary organization of protection of objects or for the protection of damaged areas of stationary perimeter security systems.
Photo 5. External appearance of the transceiver
The Vitim system consists of a number of transceivers located on special portable stands (photo 5), a data processing and transmission unit and a remote indication unit (photo 6), which displays signals about a violation of the controlled area with an indication of the location of the violation and equipment malfunction signals.
The signals are transmitted to the remote indication unit via a radio channel or a wired communication line at a distance of up to 15 or up to 3 km, respectively.
The system is powered autonomously (10НКГЦ1б battery) or using a group power supply kit.
Installation of transceivers on special racks allows creating a continuous security line on the ground with a length of up to 1.0 … 1.5 km by means of 10 sections. A radio beam is used to transmit information about a violation of a section, which actually forms the detection zone.
The last receiving stand is equipped with a VHF transceiver, which provides communication with the remote indication unit via one of five fixed frequency channels (photo 6).
Photo 6. Remote indication unit VBI-R with antenna
Mobile quickly deployable radio beam security system with information transmission via radio channelMobil-RLD, developed by NIKIRET (Zarechny), is in many ways an analogue of the Vitim system, although it has significant differences. The system allows for the rapid organization of perimeter protection of a territory, extending from 0.05 to 1.25 km, with the possibility of increasing the extent by increasing the number of blocked areas.
Unlike the Vitim system, each of the Mobile-RLD zones is formed by a separate set of a two-position radio beam sensor model RLD-94DR. Therefore, the controlled areas can be located on the ground in any order without any connection with each other. The packaging set for the receiver and transmitter of each section of the Mobile-RLD system is rigid rectangular boxes that are used to install antennas on the ground.
Therefore, full functioning of the system is possible on unprepared terrain, including sandy and marshy soils.
The Mobile-RLD system generates an alarm signal when an intruder attempts to cross any of the ten detection zones, transmitting a signal up to 1.5 km via a radio channel indicating the number of the area where the intrusion occurred, with subsequent memorization and documentation of the signal information by a radio receiving monitor.
The system can operate both in an autonomous mode (powered by batteries) and in a stationary mode with power from external sources and with the transmission of alarm signals via wire lines.
For both radio beam systems under consideration, all the limitations on use inherent to two-position radio beam sensors are valid: strict requirements for the terrain, for the height of the grass and snow cover in the detection zone. Such limitations practically exclude the use of radio beam rapidly deployable systems in forests and mountainous areas.
Radio wave means “Lawn”is designed for the prompt blocking of temporary security lines in unprepared areas with complex terrain and line configuration (parking lots for vehicles, warehouses and storage facilities, cargo areas).
The weight of the electronic unit (about 10 kg) allows us to classify this security system as quickly deployable very conditionally, however, the presence of a special set of racks for quick installation in one of the “Gazon” modifications allows you to deploy the system to a maximum length of 100 m in less than 60 minutes.
The main advantage of the «Gazon» security system is the ability to match the detection zone with the terrain and the configuration of the security line.
Photo 7. External appearance of the elements of the «Gazon» security system:
electronic unit, installation stand, wired sensitive element on a coil
A wire line is deployed along the protected area at a height of 1.5-1.8 m from the ground and connected to the electronic unit (photo 7). The wire line is secured to dielectric posts installed in the ground every 7-9 m. A lower wire is laid under the upper wire along the ground surface. A volumetric detection zone is formed between the upper wire and the ground surface. The electronic unit records changes in the electromagnetic field when an intruder appears in the detection zone.
The «Gazon» security system can operate both in stand-alone mode and in conjunction with data collection and processing systems. For use in stand-alone mode, the electronic unit is powered by a 10NKGTS-1D battery.
The operating limitations are the height of the grass and snow cover (no more than 0.6 m).
In addition, the detection zone requires maintaining the following distances from objects and items:
- tree crowns — 2 m;
- vehicles — 5 m;
- power lines — 20 m
The length of the blocked line for the “Gazon” system is from 40 to 100 m, with every 10° deviation from the rectilinear direction of the security line reducing its length by 1 m. The width of the detection zone is no more than 3 m.
Detection means of the breakaway principle of operation
Detection devices of the breakaway principle can be quickly installed on the ground, have minimal weight, dimensions, and a camouflaged linear part. They are relatively cheap. The operating principle of the devices is based on the device registering a break in the DC circuit (a violation of the integrity of the sensitive element of the linear part).
Such devices are designed for the prompt blocking of temporary security boundaries (tourist campsites, vehicles, cargo areas, etc.), supplementing and strengthening the protection of individual sections of the perimeter in the directions of the likely movement of an intruder (forests, groves, ravines, etc.) and are designed for use in forested areas with arbitrary relief and configuration of the blocking area.
In the “Rod” and “Kuvshinka” devices, the sensitive element is an insulated microwire with two copper cores with a diameter of 0.1-0.2 mm and a resistance of 7-10 Ohm/m. The low mechanical strength of the microwire ensures the length of the protected boundary is no more than 100-150 m with a cassette capacity of up to 2 km. The mean time between failures of detection devices on the breakaway principle of operation usually exceeds 5000 hours.
Principle of operation The “Crab-1” detection device is based on the reflectometric method of measuring and monitoring the length of a signal wire line made of a thin, barely noticeable single insulated wire with a diameter of about 0.1 mm. Along with traditional advantages – quick deployment, portable design, cheap single wire line, the “Crab-1” series devices have the ability to continuously monitor and digitally indicate the integrity of the wire line and the distance to the place of its break.
The electronic unit design options include both autonomous operation and the ability to send an alarm signal to an external control and monitoring device.
The greatest efficiency of using breakaway devices can be achieved in conditions of very rugged terrain with dense vegetation (trees, bushes, grass) that mask the sensitive element. At the same time, vegetation, which is an interference factor for sensors of other types, does not affect the operation of breakaway devices.
Table 1. Main tactical and technical characteristics of breakaway quickly deployable detection equipment.
Name of TTX | Cable | Water Lily | Crab-1 |
Maximum length of protected area, km | 2 | 2 | 0.5 |
Temperature range, °C | -50 …+50 | — 20 …+40 | -10 …+40 |
Energy consumption: | |||
— standby mode, mA | 0.1 | 0.3 | 4 |
— “Alarm” mode, mA | 10 | 4.0 | 10 |
Voltage, V | 1.5 | 2.5 …3.0 | 0.7 …4.5 |
Power supply | A373 | 2хА316 | 3336, 3R12 |
Despite the sufficient power supply, microwire security systems are most effective in short-term security modes of 1-2 days, since the operating time to a false alarm signal does not exceed 48 hours/km and the operability of the system can only be restored after the immediate exit of the service personnel to the controlled area.
The structure of domestic rapidly deployable security systems differs from the structure of foreign systems.
A brief analysis shows that domestic and foreign rapidly deployable security systems are based on different design ideologies:
- domestic systems, like traditional perimeter security systems, monitor the linear linearof a certain length, only the design allows to reduce the time of their installation (with the loss of the level of other characteristics: reduction of the operating time to a false alarm, reduction of the time of continuous operation at the border, etc.);
- as for foreign security systems — their structure, based on concentrated and short distributed sensors, assumes monitoring not so much of the border, as of an area, the intruder's route. Almost all foreign security systems, in addition to detecting an intruder, also perform the functions of classification (single — group or people — equipment) and determining the direction of intrusion.
The difference in the ideology of construction also determines the differences in the composition of the detectors: the two-position radio beam (Vitim, Mobil-RLD) and wire-wave (Gazon) sensors used in domestic systems are not found in foreign security systems. Instead, various seismic, geophone and IR passive sensors (Rembass, CLASSIC 2000) are used.
Both approaches to building rapidly deployable security systems have a right to exist, moreover, in the future they can organically complement each other in security systems of the next generations.
In preparing the article, materials kindly provided by the Moscow representative office of the Racal concern, as well as technical documentation from NIKIRET (Zarechny), Elektrokhimpribor (Ekaterinburg) were used.