Multi-channel recording systems.
General Provisions
Recently, thanks to the improvement of computer technology (increased processor performance, the emergence of high-capacity “hard” drives, magneto-optical drives, etc.), as well as advances in the development of analog-to-digital converters (ADCs), a large number of multi-channel recording systems (MCS) have begun to appear on the special equipment market) audio information (mainly telephone conversation recording systems).
The bulk of recording systems present on the Russian market are based on personal computers, but there are devices made in the form of separate structurally and functionally complete systems, such as digital multi-channel tape recorders from EYRETEL, Great Britain.
Figure 1 shows the functional diagram of the MCR, which is common to all devices, the characteristics of which are given in Table 1.
Input analog signals Lin.1 — Lin. N (from a telephone line or another source) are sent to the interface unit, which ensures matching with the input signal source in terms of level, resistance, etc., as well as preliminary filtering of the signal.
Then the signals are sent to the input signal digitization board. This board is installed directly in the computer slot. Most often, on the ISA bus slot.
The number of channels that one input board can digitize and transmit to a computer depends on the characteristics of a specific product, but usually this number is a multiple of two, i.e. 2,4,8,16, etc.
Fig. 1
Usually all multi-channel systems have a control output, which is used to listen to the recordings made, to which you can connect headphones or speakers. Some systems also have a line output.
Some important characteristics of multichannel recording systems:
Digital data flow density — depends on the quality of digitization of the recorded signal and determines the required volume of the “hard” disk, magneto-optics or other information carriers used for archiving. Measured in MB/hour.
Note. The required disk volume is determined as:
Vd[MB] = Pw[MB/hour] * Ta[hour], where
Pw is the flow density, Ta— total time of conversations on all channels.
When recording telephone conversations, the standard is the quality of the channel in which the analog-to-digital conversion is performed by the pulse-code modulation method with a logarithmic companding characteristic, 8-bit data format and a quantization frequency of 8 kHz (for an operating frequency band of 300-3400). This digital stream corresponds to a density of 28.8 MB/hour.
For example, with such a density, only about 36 hours of recordings can be made on a 1 GB disk.
Data compression.
Almost all of the systems listed in Table 1 use some compression algorithms to reduce the density of the data flow and, accordingly, to increase the total time of recorded conversations.
However, the downside of using data compression is the deterioration of the quality of the recorded signals.
The most common algorithm that allows for acceptable quality with a fairly high compression ratio (four times) is adaptive differential pulse — code modulation ( ADPCM ), which provides a recording density of 7.2 MB/hour.
Other algorithms are also used, such as adaptive delta modulation (ADM ), but with the same compression ratio they provide slightly worse quality than ADPCM.
Connecting to a telephone line.
Typically, MSR interface units provide the ability to connect to telephone lines in parallel (similar to connecting a parallel telephone set), which is the simplest and most convenient for users.
In order for MSR sensors not to affect the monitored line, their input resistance for alternating current should be more than 10 kOhm. Some systems have the ability to connect to the line in parallel or in series.
Storing information.
Almost all MSRs use a PC “hard” disk to store information, recording onto which is carried out in the “ring” mode, which implies entering new information in place of the oldest.
For long-term archiving of information, many MSRs, in addition to “hard” disks, also include magneto-optical storage devices, onto which the required volume of already recorded information can be dumped.
Types of recording initiation.
Since the purpose of the MSR is mainly to record telephone conversations, then in order to save disk space, it is most advisable to record at the start of the conversation.
There are two main methods of starting used in the MSR — acoustic start and start by an external signal.
In the acoustic start mode, recording is turned on when the signal exceeds a certain threshold, which is set by the user.
The software of many MSRs allows you to adjust the trigger threshold separately for each channel. The signal that occurs on the line when the telephone handset is picked up is usually used as an external trigger signal.
Additional service.
Networking.
Some MSRs have the ability to increase resources by networking, and the number of channels being registered can increase almost unlimitedly.
Warning signal.
Issued by the MSR to warn subscribers who are talking that they are being recorded.
Conversion to WAV format.
Many MSRs record data to disk in their own format.
In order for the user to be able to listen to the recordings he needs on any other computer using a regular sound card (Sound Blaster), the MSR software package includes converters that convert files in the internal MSR format to the WAV format, which is playable by all sound cards.
2. MSR overview.
As can be seen from Table 1, MSRs are multifunctional devices, so a good way to evaluate a particular system would be a generalized indicator that includes such components as channel price, functionality, and recording quality.
Table 1
Manufacturer |
«Zenit-LTD» |
«Signatek» |
«Eyretel» |
«Axion» |
Russia |
Russia |
UK |
Russia |
|
Title |
«Dialogue» |
«MAG-M» |
«E1000» |
Mars-C |
Technical specifications | ||||
Number of channels in a system unit or module: min./max./step of growth |
16/32/16 |
4/16/4 |
8/48/4.8 |
8/16/4 |
ADC-DAC bit size |
n/a |
n/a |
8 |
n/a |
operating frequency band, Hz |
300-3400 |
300-3400 |
300-3400 |
300-3400 |
recording density without compression, MB/hour |
— |
n/a |
28.8 |
n/a |
recording density with max. compression, MB/hour |
10 |
n/a |
14.4 |
14.4 |
compression algorithms |
VOX |
+ |
ADIKM |
n/a |
listening without interrupting recording |
+ |
+ |
+ |
n/a |
connection to telephone lines (parallel/sequential) |
+/+ |
+/- |
+/- |
+/+ |
input. resistance according to AC current (for parallel connection), kOhm |
n/a |
>=100 |
>=30 |
>=27 |
Outputs | ||||
linear/control (headphones, acoustic speakers) |
+/+ |
-/+ |
+/+ |
-/+ |
Information storage and retrieval | ||||
hard drive/external removable media |
+/- |
+/+ |
+/+ |
+/+ |
date/time/duration |
+/+/+ |
+/+/+ |
+/+/+ |
+/+/- |
by channel number |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
by phone number |
+ |
+ |
+ |
— |
others criteria |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
Types of recording trigger | ||||
acoustic start/external signal/other methods |
+/+/+ |
+/+/+ |
n/a |
+/+/+ |
Additional service | ||||
determination of incoming number (Caller ID) |
+ |
+ |
+ |
& #8212; |
outgoing number identification |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
networking |
+ |
+ |
+ |
— |
warning signal |
— |
— |
+ |
— |
convert to WAV format |
+ |
+ |
— |
n/a |
access restrictions |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
working with fax messages |
— |
— |
+ |
— |
possibility of digital processing of recordings |
— |
+ |
— |
|
working with digital lines |
ISDN, E1, T1 |
— |
E1, T1 |
— |
Certificate of Conformity of the Ministry of Communications |
+ |
n/a |
n/a |
+ |
Structural design | ||||
PC based/autonomous device |
+/- |
+/- |
-/+ |
+/- |
PC Requirements | ||||
processor |
386 and above |
P120 and above |
— |
P100 and above |
RAM, MB |
8 |
16 |
— |
8 |
video adapter |
VGA |
SVGA |
— |
SVGA |
hard drive, MB* |
n/a |
2100 |
— |
1200 |
expansion bus |
ISA |
n/a |
— |
n/a |
operating system |
Windows-95/NT |
OS/2 Warp4.0 |
— ; |
n/a |
DOS 6.22,Win95 |
— |
|||
Overall dimensions, mm |
s.b. PC |
s.b. PC |
485x180x620 |
s.b. PC |
Weight, kg |
s.b. PC |
s.b. PC |
no more than 20 |
s.b. PC |
Power consumption, W |
s.b. PC |
s.b. PC |
no more than 150 |
s.b. PC |
Average cost of 1 channel, $ US** |
n/a |
530 |
850 |
385 |
“ + “ — yes, “ — “ — no, n/a — no data; s.b. PC — PC system unit.
* — indicates the volume recommended by the manufacturer. To select the volume you need, see the note to Chapter 1.
** — is determined by dividing the cost of the max. number of channels by the number of channels. The cost of the PC is not taken into account.
Table 1. Continued
Manufacturer |
«Estra» |
«Estra» |
«Estra» |
«MDG» |
Russia |
Russia |
Russia |
Russia |
|
Name |
«MSR» |
«MSR’97» |
«MSR-Compact-Pro» |
«Forget-me-not» |
Technical characteristics | ||||
possible number of channels. in the system unit or module: |
4-6-8-12-16-32 |
4-8-16 |
2-4-8-12 |
|
min/max/increase step |
8/32/2 |
|||
ADC-DAC bit size |
12 |
12, |
12 |
16 |
worker lane frequencies, Hz |
300-3500 |
300-3400 |
300-3500 |
100-4700 |
recording density without compression, MB/hour |
43.2 |
43.2 |
43.2 |
60 |
recording density with max. compression, MB/hour |
7.2 |
7.2 |
7.2 |
14 |
compression algorithms |
ADICM |
ADICM |
ADICM |
ADICM |
listening without interrupting recording |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
connection to telephone. lines (parallel/serial) |
+/- |
+/- |
+/- |
+/- |
input. resistance according to AC current (for parallel connection), kOhm |
>10 |
>20 |
>10 |
>10 |
Outputs | ||||
linear/control (headphones, acoustic speakers) |
-/+ |
-/4 exit |
-/+ |
+/+ |
Information storage and retrieval | ||||
hard drive/external removable media |
+/+ |
-/+ |
+/+ |
+/+ |
date/time/duration |
+/+/- |
+/+/- |
+/+/- |
+/+/+ |
by channel number |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
by phone number |
— |
— |
— |
— |
other criteria |
+ |
+ |
+ |
— |
Types of recording trigger | ||||
acoustic start/external signal/other methods |
+/+/+ |
+/+/+ |
+/-/+ |
+/+/- |
Additional service | ||||
determination of incoming number (Caller ID) |
+ |
— |
— |
+ |
outgoing number identification |
+ |
— |
— |
+ |
networking |
+ |
+ |
— |
+ |
warning signal |
— |
— |
— |
+ |
conversion to WAV format |
+ |
— |
n/a |
+ |
access restriction |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
working with fax messages |
— |
— |
— |
— |
possibility of digital processing of recordings |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
working with digital lines |
— |
— |
— |
— |
Certificate of Conformity of the Ministry of Communications |
+ |
+ |
+ |
— |
Structural design | ||||
PC based/standalone device |
+/- |
+/- |
+/- |
+/- |
PC Requirements |
*** |
*** |
*** |
|
processor |
P100 and above |
|||
RAM, MB |
8 |
|||
video adapter |
SVGA |
|||
hard disk, MB* |
1200 |
|||
expansion bus |
n/a |
|||
operating system |
Windows 3.11 |
|||
Overall dimensions, mm |
n/a |
n/a |
n/a |
s.b. PC |
Weight, kg |
n/a |
n/a |
n/a |
s.b. PC |
Power consumption, W |
<150 |
n/a |
**** |
s.b. PC |
Average cost of 1 channel, $ US** |
870 |
840 |
820 |
960 |
“ + “ — yes, “ — “ — no, n/a — no data; PC system unit — PC system unit.
* — indicates the volume recommended by the manufacturer. To select the volume you need, see the note to Chapter 1.
** — is determined by dividing the cost of the max. number of channels by the number of channels. The cost of the PC is not taken into account
*** — this system is not supplied without a PC. The characteristics and design of the PC are determined by the manufacturer.
**** — power is supplied from a 12V battery.
Table 1. Continued
Manufacturer |
“Surtel” |
“Surtel” |
«Gran — When» |
«Hummock» |
Russia |
Russia |
Russia |
Russia |
|
Name |
“Memory — 1” |
“DTRS” |
«Stelth Line» |
«Tembr-002» |
Technical specifications | ||||
Number of channels in the system unit or module: |
8-16 |
16 |
8-16-32 |
|
min/max/increase step |
2/64/2.8 |
|||
ADC-DAC bit size |
8 |
8 |
16 |
n/a |
operating frequency band, Hz |
300-4000 |
300-3400 |
300-3500 |
n/a |
recording density without compression, MB/hour |
30 |
28.8 |
28.8 |
n/a |
recording density with max. compression, MB/hour |
7.5 |
1.25 |
7.2 |
5.0 |
compression algorithms |
n/a |
n/a |
ADKM |
ADM |
listening without interrupting recording |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
connection to telephone. lines (parallel/serial) |
n/a |
n/a |
+/- |
n/a |
input. resistance according to AC current (for parallel connection), kOhm |
n/a |
n/a |
>70 |
n/a |
Outputs | ||||
linear/control (headphones, acoustic speakers) |
-/+ |
-/+ |
-/+ |
-/+ |
Information storage and retrieval | ||||
hard drive/external removable media |
+/+ |
+/- |
+/+ |
+/- |
date/time/duration |
+/+/+ |
+/+/+ |
+/+/+ |
+/+/+ |
by channel number |
+ |
+ |
+ |
+ |
by phone number |
+ |
+ |
+ |
— |
other criteria |
+ |
+ |
+ |
— |
Types of recording trigger | ||||
acoustic trigger/external signal/other methods |
+/-/- |
-/+/- |
+/+/+ |
n/a/ |
Additional service | ||||
determination of the incoming number (Caller ID) |
+ |
+ |
+ |
— |
outgoing number identification |
+ |
+ |
+ |
— |
merging to the network |
— |
— |
+ |
— |
warning signal |
— |
— |
+ |
— |
conversion to WAV format |
n/a |
n/a |
+ |
— |
access restriction |
+ |
+ |
+ |
— |
working with fax messages |
— |
— |
+ |
— |
working with digital lines |
— |
— |
E1,T1,ISDN |
— |
Certificate of Conformity of the Ministry of Communications |
— |
— ; |
+ |
— |
Design | ||||
PC-based/standalone device |
+/- |
automatic unit, connected via ETHERNET to PC |
+/- |
+/- |
PC Requirements | ||||
processor |
486DX4-100 and above |
P166 and above |
486 and above |
386 and above |
RAM, MB |
12 |
12 |
8 |
8 |
video adapter |
SVGA to PCI bus |
SVGA |
SVGA |
SVGA |
hard drive, MB* |
1300 |
2100 |
1300 |
1300 |
expansion bus |
ISA |
— |
ISA |
n/a |
operating system |
Windows 95 |
Windows 95 OSR2 |
DOS 6.22 Win95/NT |
n/a |
Overall dimensions, mm |
s.b. PC |
410x320x90 |
s.b. PC |
s.b. PC |
Weight, kg |
s.b. PC |
n/a |
s.b. PC |
s.b. PC |
Power consumption, W |
s.b. PC |
<=100 |
s.b. PC |
s.b. PC |
Average cost of 1 channel, $ US** |
375 |
438 |
500 |
n/a |
“ + “ — yes, “ — “ — no, n/a — no data; s.b. PC — PC system unit.
* — indicates the volume recommended by the manufacturer. To select the volume you need, see the note to Chapter 1.
** — is determined by dividing the cost of the max. number of channels by the number of channels. The cost of the PC is not taken into account.
Table 1. End
Manufacturer |
«Artix — Line» |
«Alexen» |
Russia |
Russia |
|
Name |
«Black Box» |
«Echo +” |
Technical characteristics | ||
number of channels in a system unit or module: | ||
min/max/increase step |
2/72/2,4,16 |
4/16/4 |
ADC-DAC bit size |
8 |
8 |
operating frequency band, Hz |
300-3400 |
300-3000 |
recording density without compression, MB/hour |
28.8 |
16 |
recording density with max. compression, MB/hour |
10 |
8 |
compression algorithms |
VOX |
A-low |
listening without interrupting recording |
+ |
+ |
connection to telephone. lines (parallel/serial) |
+/- |
+/- |
input. resistance according to AC current (for parallel connection), kOhm |
n/a |
>200 |
Exits | ||
linear/control (headphones, acoustic speakers) |
-/+ |
-/+ |
Information storage and retrieval | ||
hard drive/external removable media |
+/+ |
+/- |
date/time/duration |
+/+/+ |
+/+/- |
by channel number |
+ |
+ |
by phone number |
— |
— |
other criteria |
— |
— |
Types of recording start | ||
acoustic start/external signal/other methods |
n/a |
+/+/-/ |
Additional service | ||
incoming number identification (Caller ID) |
+ |
— |
outgoing number identification |
— |
— |
networking |
— |
— ; |
warning signal |
— |
— |
conversion to WAV format |
+ |
+ |
access restriction |
+ |
+ |
working with fax messages |
— |
— |
working with digital lines |
— |
— |
Certificate of Conformity of the Ministry of Communications |
& #8212; |
— |
Design | ||
PC-based/standalone device |
+/- |
+/- |
PC requirements | ||
processor |
P166 and above |
486 and above |
RAM, MB |
16 |
4 |
monitor |
SVGA |
VGA |
hard drive , MB** |
1.3 |
1.3 |
expansion bus |
ISA |
ISA |
operating system |
Windows 95/NT |
DOS 5 and older |
Overall dimensions, mm |
s.b. PC |
s.b. PC |
Weight, kg |
s.b. PC |
s.b. PC |
Power consumption, W |
s.b. PC |
s.b. PC |
Average cost of 1 channel, $ US*** |
650 |
440 |
“ + “ — yes, “ — “ — no, n/a — no data;s.b. PC — PC system unit.
* — indicates the volume recommended by the manufacturer. To select the volume you need, see the note to Chapter 1.
** — is determined by dividing the cost of the max. number of channels by the number of channels. The cost of the PC is not taken into account.
Unfortunately, MSR manufacturers do not provide such an important parameter as loss of intelligibility in the recording path—playback in the specifications of their devices., although almost all systems use speech signal compression, so the quality of a particular system can only be assessed indirectly, by the digital stream density and compression algorithm.
Table 2 allows you to compare the MSRs according to the above generalized criterion.
Note: The functional capabilities are indicated in conventional units on a twenty-point scale.
Table 2.
Channel price, |
Recording density, |
Algorithm |
Functional |
Certificate |
|
$ US |
Mb |
compression |
opportunities |
Ministry of Communications |
|
Memory -1 |
375.00 |
7.5 |
n/a |
13 |
— |
Mars — C |
385.00 |
n/a |
n/a |
14 |
+ |
DTRS |
438.00 |
1.25 |
n/a |
14 |
— |
Echo + |
440, 00 |
8 |
A-Low |
10 |
— |
Stelth-Line |
500.00 |
7.2 |
ADICM |
20 |
+ |
MAG-M |
530.00 |
n/a |
n/a |
19 |
n/a |
Black Box |
650.00 |
10 |
VOX |
11 |
— |
MCP-Compact-Pro |
820.00 |
7.2 |
ADICM |
13 |
+ |
MSR-97 |
840.00 |
7.2 |
ADICM |
14 |
+ |
E1000 |
850.00 |
14.4 |
ADICM |
17 |
n/a |
MSR |
870.00 |
7.2 |
ADICM |
18 |
+ |
Forget-me-not |
960.00 |
14 |
ADICM |
17 |
— |
Dialog |
n/a |
10 |
VOX |
20 |
+ |
Timbre-002 |
n/a |
5.0 |
ADM |
8 |
— |
The comparison results allow us to first note the “Stelth Line systems” (the “Grand Prix” company) and “MAG-M” (the “Signatek” company), which have a wide range of functional capabilities and have a relatively low cost per channel.
However, this is true for the case when the user purchases a system with the maximum number of channels; when purchasing a system with a small number of channels, the cost can increase significantly.
The “Stelth Line” system series includes a wide range of models — from “Stelth Line Mini” (6 channels) to “Stelth Line Big Professional”, which allows recording up to 64 channels. In the multi-user functional mode for the “Stelth Line Big Professional” system, the number of recording channels is not limited.
The system operates in the Windows NT operating system, using all the advantages of network technology.
The “Stelth Line” systems use a self-test mode when turned on or during operation, allowing for prompt detection of a malfunction.
“MAG-M”.
The products of the company «Signatek» include both autonomous systems (MAG-M4, MAG-M8, MAG-M16), implemented on the basis of a PC with a Pentium processor and the OS/2 Warp operating system, and network systems, based on both a local (MAG-ME) and a global network (MAG-MG).
Network systems allow servicing up to 256 channels and operate under the Novell NetWare 4.1 operating system.
It is necessary to note the high noise immunity and fault tolerance of the equipment, which is achieved by a combination of various software and hardware methods.
The next group of MSRs is relatively simple and inexpensive ($375-440 per channel) systems and, accordingly, possessing much smaller functional capabilities. These include “Memory — 1” and “DTRS” (Surtel company), “Mars-Ts” (Axion company), “Echo +” (Aleksen company).
In this group, the DTRS” system is of particular interest.
The peculiarity of this system is that the digitalization boards are not installed directly into the system unit as in other systems, but are placed in a separate, structurally complete module connected to the PC system unit via the ETHERNET.
The system is designed to record 16 channels, each of which can have its own compression mode.
This MSR is also characterized by the highest degree of input signal compression among all others (maximum — 23 times).
The third group includes systems that have fairly broad functionality, good recording quality, but are relatively expensive (over $800 per channel).
Here, first of all, it is necessary to note the “E1000” system (by “EYRETEL”) and the “Nezabudka” MSR (by “CRT”).
The E1000 is a professional digital tape recorder, made as an autonomous unit.
Special highly reliable digital DAT cassettes are used to archive recordings.
It is possible to connect up to 256 tape recorders into a network, each of which can record up to 48 channels.
“Nezabudka” is has the means of operational documentation of sound recording in the selected channel, as well as a unique opportunity to compare the typed text and the corresponding sound.
The connection between text and speech is established automatically and allows in the typed text. when moving the cursor to an arbitrary fragment of text, to instantly find and listen to the corresponding fragments of the speech signal.