ACS of leading foreign manufacturers.
Writing about these systems is easy and difficult at the same time.
Easy, firstly, because their quality and reliability are confirmed by many thousands of installations in dozens of countries.
Secondly, because manufacturing companies invest huge amounts of money in developing new products and developing their own production facilities. Therefore, the highest hardware performance of controllers, a virtually non-stop innovation process is the lot of leading American and European manufacturers.
Anyone who has visited, say, the APOLLO plants in Newport Beach or NEDAP in Groenlo understands the scale of production we are talking about. Whatever they say about the current international division of labor, about how in the age of integration everyone should do their own narrow business, giving work to outsourcing companies, one cannot help but take into account that the TSB market is much more conservative than, say, the computer market. Here, more than anywhere else, it is important to control the entire process from start to finish. And having your own production (usually a full cycle, including printed circuit boards and other electronic components) is an obvious competitive advantage. It is clear that a company can afford to maintain its own production only if it has the appropriate sales markets, and not only in its own country, but also in dozens of other countries.
The next factor, as trite as it may sound, is the experience of leading European and American manufacturers. This is a very broad concept, including technical developments in the software and hardware of systems, and the technological level, and the culture of production. Just as nine women will not be able to give birth to a child in a month, such experience cannot appear at once. Even if we assume that, for example, tomorrow a team of geniuses will begin developing some system, which, moreover, is absolutely not constrained by funds, it will still be forced to first catch up with those who have been leaders for many decades.
The same can be said about the experience of implementing systems. The fact is that if a company has reached the Russian market, this means that it has international experience (the key word here is international) in implementing its systems, and not only in its own country, but also in other countries. Those companies that work seriously in Russia have incomparably more experience in the access control market than the age of our security market as a whole. In quantitative terms, the systems of leading brands owned by American and European companies make up, according to experts, almost half of all TSB offered on the Russian market. Even more impressive are such indicators as the monetary equivalent and growth rates (at least those that have been observed in the last few years) of system implementation. This is very similar to the situation that has developed, for example, in the automobile market, where the segment of sales of foreign cars in monetary terms and in growth rates significantly outstrips the sales of domestic auto industry products.
Who is the consumer
Obviously, the controversy about which ACS is preferable for the Russian market is completely inappropriate in this review. We will try to avoid it, although the search for an answer to the eternal consumer question: what to choose, is ultimately the goal and quintessence of any review article.
No one argues that in Russia they know how to make (and do make) reliable and affordable systems for a large mass of customers. But when it comes to systems for large distributed objects, when it is necessary to process huge data arrays with a large number of events, a number of visitors in the tens of thousands, the question of controller performance, detailed development of software, reliable algorithms for integration with other subsystems arises.
A permanent Russian consumer of ACS of leading foreign manufacturers is, among other things, foreign companies. More precisely, their representative offices in the Russian Federation. The fact is that the offices of most network structures are equipped in accordance with fairly strict corporate standards, which also apply to technical security equipment.
And for the headquarters of a network company, an office in Moscow or Yekaterinburg is no different from any other office, be it in Brazil, Slovenia or Germany.
In order for the equipment of a particular manufacturer to fall into the corporate standard, it is not enough to make high-quality equipment, although, as a rule, a well-known and strong brand is essentially a synonym for quality and reliability. There is one more indispensable condition: the manufacturer must be a real participant in the international market.
Of course, no one will take seriously a company that pompously spreads the news that it has installed its controllers on three doors in an English pub. International business is when a company has representative offices and distributors in countries that are serious consumers of ACS, and when it has not just experience working in a specific country, but experience that can be used to successfully conduct business in any region of the world.
It should be noted that today many Russian companies have also developed their own corporate standards for technical security equipment used in offices and other facilities. The customers of ACS from leading foreign manufacturers are, first of all, large companies: banks, industrial enterprises, office centers.
But it is not always about installing large systems. The very flexible Western market offers consumers a huge range of systems, as they say, for every taste and budget. Do you need to securely close two doors of a small office from unauthorized access? By choosing an ACS from one of the leading brands, you will do it easily, quickly and reliably. Do you need a network ACS for your facility? You can be sure that you will find the best solution among the offers of European and American manufacturers. Are you designing an integrated security system for a large geographically distributed facility? Most of the foreign ACS available on the market allow you to ensure the construction of an integrated security system at the facility, including video surveillance, as well as security and fire alarms.
Almost any of the systems has unlimited expansion capabilities. Even autonomous devices often have a centralized operating mode, which is used when it is necessary to expand the system.
Myths and Reality
It can be difficult to write about these systems, primarily because a large part of the market is captive to myths. These myths are about as old as the Russian security market, which, as you may recall, began with the import of foreign equipment.
The first myth is the high cost of «branded» systems. What can be said here? Indeed, most ACS of the world's leading manufacturers occupy the upper price niche. What is more productive and technologically advanced is, of course, more expensive. But, firstly, most of the lines presented on the market also have budget options. And secondly, cost is only one indicator. A very important one, but still one of the others. Western consumers are guided by the price/quality ratio, and each component is equally important to them.
The second myth is problems with warranty and post-warranty service.
This myth is probably the most widespread and persistent today, because it was a reality not so long ago. Today, the situation has changed radically. These changes are primarily related to changes in the Russian TSB market. It is growing, and it is becoming profitable for Western manufacturers to adapt their systems for the Russian consumer. This is a general trend, but this is especially true for ACS. The software is localized properly and in the right time. Competent technical support, built according to Western standards, has appeared and is developing, which is provided by both foreign and Russian specialists who have undergone all the necessary training. Our market is a market with great potential, and serious companies work here very seriously. Including in organizing technical support. Moreover, American and European manufacturers have a very large and good experience in such adaptation of systems in markets similar in terms of basic criteria: in Eastern Europe, Asia, Latin America.
In the review part of the publication, readers will be able to familiarize themselves in detail with the description and technical characteristics of some of the systems presented on the Russian TSB market.
APOLLO (USA)
Multi-level ACS of the highest reliability with an integrated OS has a tree-like, hierarchical structure with dedicated central controllers: AAN-100, AAN-32 and intelligent door modules of ACS AIM-4SL/2SL/1SL. Provides hardware storage of cards and events on two levels at once. The system can also be equipped with AIO-168/16/8 security and relay panels, ASA-72 status display panels, building automation control panels (elevators, etc.). The most powerful AAN-100 controllers can control 96 readers, remember up to 1,240,934 card numbers, allow connecting up to 512 security loops and 608 relay outputs to one controller.
All controllers can be connected to a computer, from which they can be programmed, access controlled and events monitored with their recording on a PC. At the same time, they can all operate completely autonomously, saving the event protocol and sending it to the computer on demand. Connection to the computer is carried out via RS-232/RS-485 or Ethernet, connection of central controllers with slave modules and security panels is possible both via RS-485 and Ethernet, which allows building modern ACS based on IP technologies. Control software packages (PC) for working with APOLLO equipment — PC APACS 3000 and PC LyriX.
The equipment allows for the organization of complex access modes: entry with two cards, a mode for limiting the number of people in a room or a group of rooms combined into one zone, time and zone antipassback, limiting attempts to enter a code, “access under duress,” etc.
In turn, the APACS 3000 and LyriX software packages provide extensive service functions that complement the capabilities of the APOLLO equipment. Among them, we can mention working time accounting, control of all events in the system, direct interactive control of equipment and the system from facility plans, issuance of reports according to specified criteria, integration with third-party equipment to create integrated security systems (ISS), etc.
WIN-PAK Professional Edition (Honeywell)
WIN-PAK® Professional Edition is the latest version of Honeywell software for access control and management systems and complex integrated security systems. The professional version supports PW-5000, PRO2200, N-1000, NStar NS2+ series ACS controllers, as well as new controllers with a built-in NetAXS Web server. Unlike software products from other manufacturers, WIN-PAK is implemented as a set of Windows services running in the background. This ensures exceptional system stability regardless of operator actions. The program has a Web interface for performing all functions and supports operation on multiple monitors.
For each cardholder, it is possible to record in the database not only a photograph, but also images of documents, a car or a laptop. This allows you to control the passage of employees and visitors with equipment. The new version has added functions for working with e-mail, which allows you to automatically generate and send reports and messages about events by e-mail. Reports on the frequency of card use make it possible to identify and deactivate cards that are not used in the system.
The PW-5000 and PRO2200 controllers allow you to implement virtually any control algorithms for actuators thanks to the built-in programmable logic, which makes it possible to link events and actions (procedures) performed in the system at the controller hardware level.
With the help of the LobbyWorks electronic visitor accounting system, also integrated into WIN-PAK, you can now manage visitor access and issue cards with a limited access level, valid only for the duration of the visit. The cards automatically become inactive after the visitor's visit.
WIN-PAK provides full integration with digital video recorders (e.g. Fusion), analog and IP cameras. Events occurring in various security subsystems are linked to video fragments to enable visual monitoring of ongoing or past events. The movement tracking function allows displaying a list of people in any room in real time and counting their number.
Casi Rusco (GE) Access Control System
The Casi Rusco access control system is unique in that it is the only system of its kind that works reliably with a very large number of readers and supports both Windows and Linus/Unix operating systems, and not only SQL databases, but also Oracle, DB2. Almost all systems in the world that have 3,000 or more readers are built on Casi Rusco. In total, more than 10,000 systems on Windows and more than 000 systems on Linus/Unix have been installed in 65 countries.
Large Casi Rusco systems are built on the Linus/Unix OS on the Picture Perfect 4.0 platform, which meets the needs of large corporations with many objects and high performance requirements. The Picture Perfect 4.0 platform is an exclusive Java client, it is resistant to virus attacks, has unlimited expandability. User reports, a customizable interface, integration/XMLAPI, server redundancy using PXNplus technology, support for AIX and Linux platforms — these and other system functions invariably attract users.
Another Casi Rusco solution — from small to large distributed systems — is Facility Commander for Windows OS (FCWnx) with flexible options for integrating video and other subsystems.
FCWnx has a single user interface, the ability to provide information from systems in a single format, reducing the time for evaluation and decision-making. Equipped with such functions as automatic event management, an open database and API for integration.
FCWnx has three versions: Professional (up to 5 clients and 256 readers), Enterprise (up to 50 clients and 4000 readers), Global (up to 64 regional Enterprise-level servers).
At the same time, both systems (Picture Perfect and FCWnx) have a single line of M series controllers (M5, M2000, M3000) with support for up to 16 readers and connection via RS485 and Ethernet.
In addition, Casi Rusco has a network IP controller DirecDoor, which is a reliable alternative to IP readers. It is installed on each door, is powered via Ethernet and supports two readers, which allows you to create a distributed, low-cost system, while having all the benefits of Picture Perfect and FCWnx.
The Casi Rusco system includes special Transition Readers – transition readers that support four access card formats: GE Proximity, HID, MIFARE, VICINITY. All of the listed card formats can be simultaneously supported in a single ACS database, which allows you to support tenants with different card formats in one system.
OnGuard ACS from Lenel with support for an unlimited number of readers and access cards
The OnGuard Access standalone/networked access control system from Lenel Systems International is an integral part of the OnGuard platform and can serve both small and very large facilities: office buildings, airports, educational institutions, etc. It consists of the OnGuard Access software module and hardware — controllers, input/output modules for security sensors/actuators, RFID and biometric reader control modules and readers from various manufacturers.
One of the main advantages of the OnGuard ACS is the reliability and stability of its operation with very large volumes of data. The system is easily scalable without replacing equipment and reinstalling software: you only need to purchase the necessary licenses, controllers, modules and servers. Even if you start building a system with just one reader, you can expand it to an unlimited number of readers with minimal costs. At the same time, as the system grows, the transaction processing time does not increase, and the Lenel ACS can service an unlimited number of access points (doors, turnstiles, barriers) and access cards.
Having initially installed one software module for the ACS, the consumer can always supplement it with a video surveillance system, security, fire alarm and other systems. In this case, the different components of the system will work with a single database, with single source software codes and use a single graphical interface for all applications.
OnGuard Lenel is based on the latest technologies, including object-oriented programming, client-server database architecture, and operation on the multitasking and multithreaded 32-bit Windows 2000/XP/2003 operating system. For «seamless» integration with applications and equipment already operating in the enterprise's IT infrastructure, the OnGuard platform is equipped with special tools.
Another undoubted advantage of the OnGuard ACS is its full integration with software and digital video recording devices DVR and NVR from Lenel to create a video surveillance system. Both analog and IP cameras can be used, and the Russified IntelligentVideo software is used to analyze video data, which allows you to determine the route of an object, tracks crowded areas, adapts the system to changing lighting conditions and detects unauthorized impacts on cameras. In general, the Lenel video surveillance system is event-oriented, where any action is initiated by one of the recorded incidents.
Keri Systems' Standalone/Networked Access Control System
The access control system of Keri Systems, which has been present on the Russian market for a long time and is constantly updated, has proven itself as a system with high reliability, simple assembly and installation, easy administration and cost-effectiveness in operation. An additional advantage of this system is free Russified software for ACS administration and the availability of software for accounting of working hours, adapted to the requirements of Russian labor legislation. In addition, this ACS is integrated with the video surveillance system through the Visions application software.
The low-budget access control system can process information from proximity cards of 50 to 65,000 employees per controller, control up to 256 doors, allowing you to register up to 32 system administrators and assign up to 32 time zones with an unlimited number of access groups. The Doors software included in the delivery set allows you to display photos of employees being identified on the reader on the security monitor and print passes on proximity cards.
The Keri Systems ACS may include the following components:
PXL-500/510 Tiger II controllers
Russified Doors software (free)
Timex time tracking system
Access card readers, biometric readers, intercoms
Identification passes (cards or key fobs)
Integrated video surveillance system Visions.
Multifunctional Doors software for Keri Systems ACS Doors software is fully Russified, works with Windows 9x/2000/ME/XP/NT OS and provides access to remote system nodes via IP network or modem connection. In autoconfiguration mode, Doors automatically polls controllers and configures the system in accordance with the devices found in the network. As a functional component of the Doors software, the Visions software for the video surveillance system is also integrated into the Keri Systems ACS, the hardware of which is implemented on the basis of a multi-channel video capture card. The Visions program allows you to receive a video image associated with events in the access control system.
SiPass® integrated (Siemens)
The SiPass® integrated system is designed to solve access control problems ranging in complexity from medium to very high. The system is ideal for existing facilities and new buildings. Unlimited flexibility allows access control in a low-rise office or residential building with just a few doors, as well as in large multi-story complexes with tens of thousands of doors, gates, fences and elevators in many locations around the world. The total number of SiPass® integrated cardholders is virtually unlimited.
Standardized interfaces allow for easy integration into existing security and business systems. A wide range of software extensions makes it possible to customize the system.
In addition to providing the functionality of an advanced access control system, SiPass® integrated supports integration with video surveillance systems, security and fire alarms developed not only by Siemens, but also by other companies, which ensures the creation of a comprehensive security solution.
The SiPass® integrated system consists of various hardware components: central controllers, door modules, signal modules, readers and cards. Automatic backup and recovery of the system database is supported. Secure data transmission along the entire information route, from the identification card to the server, guarantees a high level of protection.
The reliable and user-friendly SiPass® integrated software is the core of the system. The Windows-certified software uses a powerful client/server architecture and is easy to install and configure using a graphical user interface. Features such as movement tracking, advanced alarm management, anti-passback, an interface to matrix switches and digital video recorders, as well as support for a customizable Wiegand interface and a firmware update mode for devices, are standard in the SiPass® integrated system. Many other specialized features are available as options.
Nedap-AEOS Access Control and Management Systems (Netherlands)
AEOS is a powerful, user-friendly access control and security management system based on intelligent network technology. In AEOS, core functionality is shaped according to end-user wishes through peer-to-peer information flow and flexible behavioral components. Using the latest information technology, AEOS offers a reliable and future-oriented solution to all your security needs now and in the future.
Easy to use, accessible without restrictions AEOS is based on web technology. This means that you can connect to the system using a web browser from any computer: from another office, from another workplace, from home or even when you travel.
Decentralization of information AEOS is based on the principle of decentralized data. All access rights and programmed actions are defined and processed at the lowest level of the system. This means that system management and the required level of security are guaranteed, regardless of the availability of the network or server. The AEOS system can function independently of the server. AEOS's own IP controllers (AEpu) can communicate directly with each other and with other IP devices, such as surveillance cameras.
The expandable AEOS is made up of a variety of different hardware modules and software components, allowing you to change its configuration according to your requirements using standard components. If the situation changes, you can quickly and easily adapt or expand the hardware modules and behavioral components (embedded software) used. For the transmission of information, the AEOS system uses the existing LAN infrastructure. AEOS's own IP controllers can be connected from anywhere to the TCP/IP Ethernet 10/100 Mbit network. A VPN connection is used for communication between the controllers and the server.
AEOS was created to enable the deployment of a security management system with minimal effort and cost. That is why the software is licensed directly on a per-use basis, meaning the customer only pays for the features they use.
Edge (HID Global)
The HID Edge Global platform is an IP-based access control controller and interface solution. It is designed to provide a full-featured access control hardware/software infrastructure and contactless smart card read/write capability at the edge of the network – right at the door.
Edge products also include a multi-platform technology called OPIN™. This is an open architecture that allows it to be fully integrated into any access control system using IP network interface software. HID solution partners now have a wide variety of integrated OPIN solutions. The flexible architecture of the solution, which makes the door “smart,” includes an integrated iCLASS® reader or allows connection of any Wiegand-based reader and most HID “clok-and-data” readers.
The Edge product family includes stand-alone Edge Solo solutions for enterprises with one or more doors. With an integrated user interface, Edge Solo can operate without a centralized management system. With its OPIN technology, Edge Solo can be easily upgraded for use in centralized enterprise systems if integration into a larger system is desired. The product family also includes the Edge Host solution, which is designed for larger installations with hundreds of doors and multiple sites and is linked to a host software server on-premises. For both the Host and Solo versions, HID offers a comprehensive two-in-one card reader and access controller: the EdgeReader, in ERW400, ER40, and ESR40 versions. There are also EdgePlus E400 and ES400 access controllers, allowing end users to choose the card reader of their choice.